All Comments


Comment on piece: Joey Interviews a Cutter

User image

Review of Joey Interviews a Cutter

People expect to turn to public radio and hear what they won't hear anywhere else. THIS is a piece that you would not hear anywhere but on public radio -- a window into a life that we would never see otherwise. At first the raw nature of this put me off. I thought it was staged. But within minutes I realized it for what it was -- an incredibly valuable contribution to our understanding of others.

User image

Review of Pop Vultures #1 (deleted)

Pop Vultures should appeal to those of us who consider listening to music as part of their daily life. Better yet, it's for those of us who learned an incredible amount about the music that we heard during our "musically developing" years, but have not had the time to learn about what's happening now, and how it might possible connect with what happened back then. It seems like it should also appeal to a younger audience as it reaches into contemporary culture to help define it in terms those of us in our 40's and 50's can appreciate. Some of the voices seem a bit opinionated, but in the context of music, perfectly appropriate. It's well produced and thick with layers of talk and music. Now if we could only find room for it in our program schedule!

Comment on piece: First Menstruation Stories

User image

Review of First Menstruation Stories

As a man, I'm not sure I should have listened to it. But, I'm going to have my 13 year old daughter listen to it. Personally, I don't know if I'd want to hear this during, say, ME or TAL. Sorry, it's just me. I'm not offended or anything.

I do think it would help young girls during a scary time. Youth Radio (like the WMPG show) is obviously perfect for it, but also as some sort of chruch or school talk about bodies and getting older. This sort of intimate storytelling would be good. A video wouldn't be able to convey the information, be intimate, but not freak people out.

Misery loves company, and some of these first time stories sound like they fit that bill. An uncle shopping with you, running races, out-of-the-country. I'd almost give my daughter a computer for her bedroom just so she could listen to Blunt Radio on the internet on her own time.

Comment on piece: Family Vacation

User image

Review of Family Vacation

Anywhere, put it anywhere. I just reviewed a piece on hotels (Behind the Scenes: Housekeeping). Put this one right before it, during the vacation months. First cars, then the hotel.

Most everyone in the west, where the roads are long and people are cars are many, will have a trip story like this.

Comment on piece: Housekeeping: Behind the Scenes

User image

Review of Housekeeping: Behind the Scenes

Only disturbing because I don't want to know so much about how unclean hotels are! Deaths?! I'm gonna buy an RV.

The Gideon Bible thing is pretty interesting.

Overall, I love pieces like this. I want to do a regular series of people's jobs that I want to sound just like this. You know what -- everyone has an interesting job. The most interesting ones are the ones I don't know much about. This piece takes it down a very nice avenue, to where the employee talks not only about her job, but about how things work and of what to be careful.

Where can this fit? Well, anytime 20/20 airs one of those Dirty Hotel shows would work. Or, at the beginning of a vacation season. Best of all, some show should do a regular "At Work" series and air pieces like this once-per-week.

User image

Review of The Perfect Christmas (deleted)

If there's a PD out there doing last minute shopping consider this for Morning Edition or All Things Considered on Christmas day ...the 24th will do too.

In this commentary Duffy traces his family's Christmas traditions. Although personal, this essay will likely strike a chord with most listeners as they are prompted to reflect on their own holiday traditions.

Comment on piece: Iron Chef Geo Beach

User image

Review of Iron Chef Geo Beach

This is a station break from WKSU. In addition to the weather, underwriters-- the standard station break fare--Geo Beach offers some interesting historical facts that tie in nicely with the station's classical music identity. I particularly like hearing the school cafeteria menu. It's details like these that do give station breaks some flavor and sense of place. It's also quite polished so you don't feel that you have downgraded from listening to NPR to the local station, which is hard to do. It's difficult for many lcal NPR stations to keep the quality consistent when switching from local to national public radio.

My understanding is that this is to serve as a model for other stations. If there are program directors o who want to reinvent their station breaks than consider turning to this for inspiration.

Comment on piece: Columbia Remembered...Atlantis, Go For Launch

User image

Review of Columbia Remembered...Atlantis, Go For Launch

A well-woven, deep and prismatic look at this tragedy and the issues it raises about the space program’s value. So very poignant to hear the voices of the astronauts and spend time with them as they discuss the work they’ve set out to do. The tape of the astronauts and mission control as trouble becomes apparent is wrenching, suspenseful, despite the known outcome. We’re brought close to the aftermath through the voice of the forest ranger that found the flight recorder, and engineers discussing their efforts to figure out went wrong. A down-to-earth human angle is touched on in a visit to the hometown of the female astronaut who will command the next space shuttle. As she speaks of the practical pre-flight concerns and of their space station tasks, I find myself saying a quiet prayer for their well-being. Discussions about safety and cost concerns, and alternate ideas for space exploration, as well as the opinions of some plain old citizens about space carry us to the end of the program. This fascinating piece reminds us what a mistake it is to ever be blasé about space travel.
Air around the anniversary, or in future, around the time of any launch. sl

User image

Review of Cujo Christmas (deleted)

Funny saga with happily suitable sound accompaniment running underneath. Don’t want to give any of the story away. Not maudlin, not sappy, just a delightful one-of-a-kind holiday story about a very specific reason to rejoice. And you get to hear a doggy sung xmas carol. Can't beat that. sl

Comment on piece: The Starting Five

User image

Review of The Starting Five

Excellent piece, well produced, well written, appropriate music. It would fit anywhere, especially when talking about sports, basketball or the older generation. I especially liked the quote about the way they shot the ball and if you shot a jump shot you'd find yourself on the bench next to the coach.

I do like the piece, and obviously all of those who have a hand in it are excellent at what they do. I have a question, though: Should a story be told only by it's content, or does a producer still have room to play with it when the story is known? I'd like to hear a neoteric storytelling version of "The Starting Five".

Comment on piece: Chess Gals

User image

Review of Chess Gals

This is a really interesting piece. Given the typical PR audience, this will fit on just about any station, especially stations affiliated with universities.

So, why do few women stick with chess? Because women talk so much, while men don't? There has got be a better answer. Or, maybe that is the answer, so why look for another? Still, I was looking for at least one alternative hypothesis, but no others emerged.

I think just about everyone can relate to chess. Many of us relate to it, and thus this piece, from a family member who taught the game with glee because they found someone willing to play.

User image

Review of Tuba Christmas (deleted)

This piece offers a light-hearted view of an oddly intruiging holiday tradition. It will remind anyone who learned to play an instrument as a kid how they felt at their first recital. Better yet, it shows how being willing to look a little foolish can open you up to unexpected opportunities, like the moment David gets to share a secret smile with his son on stage.

The writing in this piece is humorous, and sprinkled with little observations that made me reflect on the character of the Holiday season, like this:

"For all our planning and attempts to make everything perfect, it seems that the thing that stick are the things we least expect."

The descriptions of people and events are also quite inventive and amusing.

I think this would be a great segment for ATC or perhaps as part of a holiday-themed package of shows.

Comment on piece: Matthew and the Judge: Juvenile Court Diary

User image

Review of Matthew and the Judge: Juvenile Court Diary

It's a privilege to be so deep inside someone's head and in this case,
inside the heads of two people on opposite sides of "the bar." I like the
way the material is organized. We meet Matthew first and get a sense of him
before we actually know everything he's done wrong, and we get to know the
judge a little before we hear them together. It's very moving to hear the judge's journey from compassionate hope to resigned disappointment, and to hear Matthew's parallel journey from hope to despair. I wanted to put my head down and cry as this piece drew to its close. Knowing Matthew is dead makes the close of this piece that much more heartbreaking. It's beautiful, respectful and could air any time, but certainly when there is big news on youth crime. sl

Comment on piece: The Future of the Planet

User image

Review of The Future of the Planet

Whole Wide World: news-compatible hour While radio tends to look at big questions through little windows, Christopher Lydon has always thrived on issues every bit as big as the whole wide world. In The Future of the Planet, he explores the questions of how we can continue to feed the planet while still trying to keep the air and water at least somewhat clean.

As his various guests -- historians and biologists, food writers, ethicists, and more -- tell us, we are just scraping by, and any one of 100,000 different things can wreak havoc in the world of Rube Goldberg globalism.

This is Lydon at his provocative best. Terrific selection of guests -- articulate and engaged -- terrific writing and wonderful elements linking the different segments of the program together.

For long-time listeners of Lydon’s old call-in show, there are moments that feel like he’s about to solicit calls and turn to the phones.

One other point: Lydon still writes a killer 60-second billboard for a news-compatible show.

Comment on piece: The Last Place: Diary of a Retirement Home

User image

Review of The Last Place: Diary of a Retirement Home

What to say? This is a poignant piece. A lovely piece. It is so good, so essential to hear from older people. With everything becoming so youthcentric--even Public Radio--it is important to listen to where where we may eventually end up.

The view from the retirement home is at times bleak, sweet, and touching. It is rare that we get to witness mortality in this way.

With a transcendent piece like this you really don't need a particular context in which to broadcast it.

If you want your listeners to stop everything they are doing, if you want your email and voicemail overflowing with gratitude--then air this piece. If you don't have a 27 minute gap then consider making room for this.

This piece originally aired on All Things Considered. I could also hear it on This American Life or Weekend Edition. -CM

Comment on piece: Stress Test

User image

Review of Stress Test

This one has a wonderfully lively style. The editing is pure pleasure and the narrative voice is smooth and real. I had a moment of wondering if it was going on too long, and the ending isn't quite the payoff I might have hoped for, but I was engaged all the way through and would air it on our station without hesitation as an ear refresher. -JA

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Pop Vultures (deleted)

For those wringing their hands over how to engage folks on the weekend or in the evening, here is one very good answer. Light, real conversational interview style, richly mixed with music (much of it recorded in the last 25 years!). This is worth listening to, if only to hear host Kate Sullivan's Sinead O'Connor imitation. Keep it up, PHP!

Comment on piece: Grass Fed Beef

User image

Review of Grass Fed Beef

'I can't talk right now, I'm listening to a radio show about grass fed beef.'

It's true, you might say this if you were listening to this piece on the radio, which is an indepth and balanced exploration of the cattle industry.

Corn-fed cattle vs. those raised on grass is at the center of this piece and inevitably larger issues are addressed: our economy , environment, and culture .

This show would be comaptible with a larger show on the economy or environment. It's something that would work on "Living on Earth," or All Things Considered, if it were shorter.

It's informative and versatile and the interviews give this piece some personality.

CM

Comment on piece: Hell's Bells

User image

Review of Hell's Bells

It seems it would do this piece--and the listener-- a disservice to reveal the content. The purpose of this piece in many ways is to witness a thought process.

In a dreamlike world where WWII soldiers are in the trenches with a turbo boom box broadcasting church bells, Anderson questions the existence of God, the darwinism of an idea vs. the creationism of an idea, and so on.

This could be used interstitially --it would be an unconventional choice for Christmas or Easter.

This is something I wouldn't be surprised to hear on Scott Simon's Weekend Edition, Day to Day, or The Next Big Thing.-CM

Comment on piece: Melissa's Diary, Part 1: Teen Mom

User image

Review of Melissa in New Haven: Teen Mom

None of the absolutes I expected to hear from a Teenage mother, negative or positive. I confess that at first, I didn't sense I was going to hear anything new and then I realized my neck hurt from leaning in. The sounds made me feel so present in that little apartment and then: the diarist tosses off some cold facts and honest feelings with the same lightness she uses to describe her social life - it's absolutely disarming. But "disarmed" you are privy to the too many layers of life and feelings cloaked in the simplicity of such a young person. Nice work.
VM