All Comments


Comment on piece: Interview about "Portrait of Billy Joe"

User image

Review of Interview about "Portrait of Billy Joe"

I'm a Billy Joe Shaver fan, yessiree, and any exposure he gets is way overdue and just fine in my book. Interviews with the director, producer, and tape of the man himself offer a good sense of why someone would go to the trouble of making a film about this unique singer songwriter, this grace guy, this terrific performer. And then you get to hear him sing. Air around any date he's in your town, or as a little culture nugget.

Comment on piece: Food Tastin

User image

Review of Food Tastin

Brief amusing look at the end of bad-for-you food days in Texas school cafeterias. Always love hearing what kids have to say about enforced change. No depth, but good to attach to more serious reporting on new public health enemy #1, obesity.

Comment on piece: Road Trip--West Coast

User image

Review of Road Trip--West Coast

A reminder that taking your time on a trip is just as important as getting there. That the journey starts when you head out the door of your house. Warga meets some great characters on this Road Trip from Seattle to L.A. via train and bus including a cab driver who promotes industrial hemp, a soldier freaked out about going back to battle, a runaway youth. This is an experiment to not drive or fly documented in audio. Warga has a great easygoing style and the piece moves you comfortably arm-char traveling. A bit long for a feature for a news magazine show. But would do well paired up with another long piece to make a great half-hour or a one-hour special with three other similiarly themed pieces about travel or personal journeys. The SOQ out is still in the piece though and would need to be trimmed or faded out for a station to use within local programming. Definitely worth a listen and consideration....Dmae

Comment on piece: The Day My Mother's Head Exploded

User image

Review of The Day My Mother's Head Exploded

PDs at newstalk stations, don't be put off by the slightly glib title -- if you audition no other PRX piece this month, listen to this one. You don't have 20 minutes to listen, so do this instead: Listen to the start, then go about 6 minutes in, then about 16. You will know then whether this terrific piece can work for your station.

This is a lovely and compelling story of a daughter and a mother whose relationship is transformed by a stroke. (The mom almost dies, and emerges, superego impaired, a new and delightful person: "I love sex now; I wasn't so crazy about it before.")

This piece, or a condensed version of it, would work well as part of a show that touches on topics including:

*mother-daughter relationships
*the cutural phenomenon of hospitalization
*kids caring for aging parents.

This is serious business, certainly, but the story is told with a light touch and an easy sense of humor. The hospital scene six minutes in is riveting, and realized beautifully as radio. There's some more amazing tape 16 minutes in -- a lovely unforced scene of disagreement between mom and daughter.

The BIG question is: How do you program this warm, amusing, deeply stereotype-busting piece? Of course this piece deserves to be heard in the full glory of its 20 minute version, but I'm afraid that length may limit its usefulness for many stations.

The most obvious local market for this -- if it's not snapped up by TAL -- may be local news-talk shows. This story could be used to focus a discussion -- by callers, by local in-studio guests -- of some of the topics mentioned above. But a local show can lose it's own sense of identity going 20 minutes without standing down and bringing in local voices. So if there is a shorter version, or a version that occurs in three or four segments, I urge the producers to make these alternatives available to stations via PRX. I think this could add significant flexibility, and could get this on the air more often, in more places, and at times of day when more people are listening. Personally, I think this is some great radio, and I want lots of people to hear it.

Comment on piece: Family

User image

Review of Family

This program belongs on every public radio station. It would best be placed at a time right after school, or mid to late morning Saturday, or early afternoon Sunday. Place it somewhere children 5-15 can hear it. A show dedicated to children's literature, I love how specific and fractured radio can be sometimes. To be able to focus this sharply and come away with a well-produced show should inspired listeners and producers alike.

Comment on piece: Michael Franti and His Roots

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Michael Franti and His Roots

This interview provides an informative context for Franti's music and inspiration. I'm not sure if Michael Franti is well known, but both he and his band definitely should be. Their songs are ecclectic--a little soul, a little funk. In any case, this little interview is a snapshot of the influences that create some really powerful music.

Comment on piece: SXSW Q&A with Matt Dentler

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of SXSW Q&A with Matt Dentler

I found this piece about the increasingly important film component at Austin's SXSW festival interesting and informative.

The final portion is rather specific to Austin residents, but the rest of the Q and A session would be of interest to broader audiences -- especially film enthusiasts. Matt Dentler addresses the surge in the popularity of documentaries -- and the rise in the number of festivals themselves. Several important new documentaries are described, as is the growing importance to indie producers of securing a slot -- and the resulting publicity -- at film fests.

Comment on piece: Wt Wd Jss Do?


Review of Wt Wd Jss Do?

The piece is short, quick, and amusing. Ian's speedy verbal interpretations of text-messaging are performed with aplomb, providing ample payoff to this essay.

Comment on piece: The Most German Day Ever

User image

Review of The Most German Day Ever

This is a smart, engaging and delightful piece that is at once incredibly parochial and yet wonderfully worldly-wise as well. A refreshing story that PDs would do well to find time for -- say, after 9 mins of hammering the listener with pledge, these 13 mins will win your audience back.

Comment on piece: The Allure of Karaoke Singing

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Allure of Karaoke Singing

Karaoke - the great equalizer. As someone in this piece says, everyone likes to sing in the car, and karaoke takes that desire to the next level. This piece has the right balance of self-deprecation and amateur performances, it is entertaining and fun and it is over just as you begin wondering where karaoke afficionados hang out in your town. Who doesn't have a secret desire to sing neil diamond songs with abandon?

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Same Sex Marriage (deleted)

Clean, concise and well written. Not too much fat but plenty to chew on. My criticism lies fully in the actual performance of the thing. It begs to be read with more realness and individual personality. Inasmuch as it is a commentary I understand the somewhat staid tone, but it has written into it a lot of humour. What is so wonderful to me about Allistair Cooke is his way of reading. It sounds as if he were speaking extemporaneously, and yet one still gets the feeling that it is an essay being recited. It draws one in and keeps one engaged.
I wasnt satisfied with the sound of the recording
EQ-compression wise, I think your voice could sound a lot warmer and more interesting.
But these are just my opinions on the audio qualities. I really did like the content.

Comment on piece: Transmitter of Things

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Transmitter of Things

Always interested in music. Was more interested in the technical info on glasses than in the person making the music. Started to lose me towards the middle, subject was not as articulate as one would have liked. I personally would have liked to have heard more extended musical excerpts from the glasses. A nice piece, just about the right length.

Comment on piece: Garbage

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Garbage

I'm glad this guy doesn't live on my block, but this is a wacky, weird, well-done piece. It's very funny in parts, and I love the background music. There's definitely an audience for this.

Comment on piece: Washington Goes To The Moon PART 1

User image

Review of Washington Goes To The Moon

The first episode brings me back to a high school moment: standing in a classroom doorway, the packed room of students and teachers silent, alert, eyes glued to the television, watching the moon become mysteriously concrete. Richard Paul’s nimble narrative of the funding challenges involved in transporting humans from here to there enriches my memory by providing a full banquet of information and experience leading up to that televised landing. I didn’t expect a program on budget funding to be so engaging, but this one is. We hear lively interview material from various historians, and scientists, as well as former White House Budget Director Charles Schultz; also, archival tape of Presidents’ Kennedy and Johnson, and other prominent voices from the sixties. Walter Cronkite offers perspective, and congressional testimony (read by actors) is included. Well-chosen music excerpts help the flow. The moon landing is considered one of our great national achievements. It is fascinating to look at it through the budget lens, as a budget line item in competition for tax dollars with the war on poverty and the war in Vietnam –– and to remember its morale boosting power in the midst of so much national turmoil –– a country divided, serious economic problems, the country at war. Kind of like right now. It’s timely listening all right, especially since Bush, however briefly, has floated a Mars balloon. Perhaps, like JFK, he sees the morale boosting potential, and similarly plans on being long gone when the bill comes due.

The second episode in many ways moves like a page-turner about tragedy and destruction. You’re immediately drawn in by an administrator’s recounting of the 1966 moment when Gemini 8 went out of control. Tape from the space docking gone awry runs alongside and underneath his compelling first-person account. It seems odd that space ships exploding in air no longer come as a shock. What almost shocks is to remember that the first astronauts to die in the space program died on the ground. Somber news reports after the Apollo One flash fire that killed three astronauts, and taut narration lead us into the heart of this piece, the aftermath and investigation into what went wrong. So much sounds familiar: NASA outsourcing work to shoddy contractors, NASA administrators scrambling to keep control of the investigation, congressional committees looking into what went wrong, concern about political influence affecting contractor appointments, investigative reports kept secret, conspiracy theories, a man’s death days after testifying before congress, a corporate culture in chaos, damage control in full force. This is the stuff of the Apollo movie that’s yet to be made. This series is timely now, or near any significant NASA dates. Can be aired as space, science, economics, history programming, or as a historical echo in light of current events today. And what was going on forty years ago, in fact, isn’t all that different: we’re at war afar, and culturally at home, the economy is rocky, poverty growing, privatization increasing. It touches on many issues on many levels.

Comment on piece: Arcade Girl

User image

Review of Arcade Girl

A good subject, thoughtfully presented. Several problems as the piece now stands: curious shifts in the script -- dense, multi-claused paragraphs in some places; nice, succinct phrasing in others. Outside elements -- the music and the interview -- are very slow in coming. Needs editing, down to perhaps 7 mins tops. Would be willing to listen again.

Comment on piece: No Email from Oaxaca

User image

Review of No Email from Oaxaca

I found this piece very striking. The pure and simple delivery (undecorated straight narration) was surprisingly effective in relaying complex concepts and emotions. The steady tone and poignant imagery completed the piece's ability to completely engage the listener. This is definatly a work that draws discussion of global development trends back to the very tangible, human realm.

Comment on piece: Juan's Diary, Part 1: Looking at the Rio Grande

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Juan in Laredo: Looking at the Rio Grande

This is a great slice-of-life piece about a young man's experience living
just over the border in the United States. In less than ten minutes, Juan
covers a wide range of emotional territory (from humor to horror, from
anguish to hope) all in a beautifully soft-spoken narrative. The ambient
sounds, music, and voices of his family make this an extremely rich piece.

Comment on piece: Lolita Unveiled: Muslim Women's Take on a Scandalous Classic

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of The Power of the Novel: Reading Lolita in Tehran

“The Power of the Novel” is a celebration of reading, an homage to the healing, redemptive power of literature. But what makes this story so moving is the sad, surprising analogy made between the little girl Lolita and the women of Tehran. The women in the story, who meet in secret to read the bizarre, disturbing, and beautiful Nabakov classic, see themselves as victims of a man’s monstrous dream—The Ayatollah—just as Lolita is a victim of Humbert’s monstrous dream. Reading helps the women escape their lives and to re-imagine themselves. Fiction, discussed in this context, reminds you of its great subversive power. And bonus: Jeremy Iron’s reading of the text is fantastic. This piece could go into a show that deals with education, the Middle East, the treatment of women, or reading. Really, it could go anywhere; it’s interesting enough.

Comment on piece: 92.5 UrbanaFM Radio, Uruguay (4min)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of 92.5 UrbanaFM Radio, Uruguay (4min)

This piece doesn't hold together as well as LaOtra. I couldn't quite figure out what was a PSA or station ID and what was part of the mix. I'd rather hear the DJ talking about the music Radio Urbana plays and why, appetites for int'l or "world" music, listener demographics... Undeniably, the station has un gran sonido.

User image

Review of Nascar Dad, Soccer Mom: Who's Next? (deleted)

Listening to Merle Kessler, aka Ian Shoales, is like careening down a steep mountain road in a sports car with no brakes. But he makes all the curves, and when he screeches to a stop with his signature "I gotta go!" sign-off, the listener is finally allowed time to breathe. With enough caffeine you can probably keep up. And maybe even notice how astute many of his observations are. He's a character, and I think one that your listeners will appreciate, maybe right away, or maybe after several hearings. He's neither bland, nor vanilla, nor beige...which is a good thing.