All Comments


Comment on piece: 'LaOtra' Female Vocal Quartet, Uruguay (4min)

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of 'LaOtra' Female Vocal Quartet, Uruguay (4min)

OOOooo... Where can I buy the CD? Usually, acapella music gives me flashbacks of bad college concerts - but what a delightful group!
I love this way of telling stories. Death to all narrators! It's harder than it sounds tho. Nice mixing, interaction caught on tape.

Comment on piece: Lang Lang: In his own words

User image

Review of Lang Lang: In his own words

Lang Lang This, like the others in the series, is very well-articulated and interesting. These quick-paced pieces offer color and insight into the featured artists without fawning or allowing the artist to engage in billowing self-indulgence. The producer also offers a nice mixture of musical genres.

Even though these are good pieces, we'd never come up with a good idea for how to use them until the producer amde a great suggestion. One of the artists (this featured artist), Lang Lang, is coming to town. Airing it is a great way to offer an interesting piece, demonstrate your connection to the arts, and not have to devote your own staff time to doing so! Another great way to let PRX make your station sound better with a minimal resource investment (sorry if that sounds like a commercial, but it’s true).

The producer might actually try to focus on touring performers, thus providing a solid local connection to stations.

Comment on piece: Stuck on a Word

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Stuck on a Word

I like this. There's this lovely, polite-sounding woman's voice counterpointed with the person's need to "cuss." The cussing points are "bleeped" throughout the piece and ask for listener participation much in the same way affirmations are requested during a religious service.

Comment on piece: 'LaOtra' Female Vocal Quartet, Uruguay (4min)

User image

Review of 'LaOtra' Female Vocal Quartet, Uruguay (4min)

The music and singers are quite charming...and the piece works on many levels, with references(or at least inferences) to feminism, Latin-American machoism, U.S. cultural dominance, romance...all in all pleasant, informative and thoughtful, a very nice combination.

Comment on piece: Turtles

User image

Review of Turtles

A personal and compelling commentary, built around a visit to a relative in a trailer park in Charlotte, North Carolina. Thorsen seems to be an honest and observant reporter. Listeners with an appetite are given plenty food for thought, and the merely curious are also well satisfied. This is good radio.

Comment on piece: The Liar's Table

User image

Review of The Liar's Table

This piece offers a rich and personal introduction into an entire community and way of life, from a simple yet highly entertaining perspective (a popular hang-out). It is a tale that may be re-invented/produced in small towns accross the US, yet is delightfully effective in conveying the unique flavors of its particular location. The textures and cadence of the piece make for a very enjoyable listening experience.

Comment on piece: This American Cheese

User image

Review of This American Cheese

Didn't work for me at all, like 14year olds making a home movie. Nothing like KUOW's "Rewind" doing 'this american car talk,' at least there the person SOUNDED like Ira glass. Not suitable for NPR's 3min slots in so many ways...

Comment on piece: "Home From Africa"

User image

Review of "Home From Africa"

This is a very good radio piece. We've heard the story before -- Post Partum Peace Corps Disorder -- but told with audio diaries and some production flourishes it sounds different and fresh. The narrator uses her Thirteen Symptoms of Chronic Peace Corps Withdrawl ("...1: subscribing to music normally only found in a library; 2: salivating to the sounds of polyrhythmic music...") as a framework to move around in time and space. We hear her reflections before, during and after her experience living in Benin, Africa nicely edited with some great African music. There's a lovely description of the proper way to clean a dirt florr. The piece ends beautifully. Newspeg: Peace Corps celebrates 43 years in March 04.

Comment on piece: Fast Food: What and Why

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Fast Food: What and Why

A few years back, I walked into a Hardee’s bathroom and found one of the kids who worked the counter sitting on a sink eating a hamburger. When I asked him why he was eating in the bathroom he told me that employees weren’t allowed to “eat on the floor.” The humanity. It’s this kind of depressing fast food pathos that Eric Schlosser, author of “Fast Food Nation” discusses in this half-hour interview. He makes the argument that not only is fast food bad because the food itself is bad for you, but also because of, among other things, the way it’s marketed to kids and the conditions that the meat packers themselves work under. But still, the food is bad for you… whatever that food may be. There’s one moment where Schlosser is invited to read off some of the “hidden” ingredients contained in the “natural flavor” of a Burger King milk shake. It’s creepy stuff. Listening to this interview on the heels of McDonald’s decision to discontinue its supersize menu (a Chevy trunk of fries served with a wading pool of Coca Cola) makes you feel like there is hope for some kind of change. This could go in any kind of newsmagazine show… on a show about health, the economy, youth culture, or the speed of urban life.

Comment on piece: Of A Piece

User image

Review of Of A Piece

Definitively the kind of piece I'd like to hear on the radio. Both Michelle and her father are consumed with the struggle to make "order out of chaos" and the jigsaw puzzles become a symbol of as well the literal place where their struggles meet. It's a look at puzzles of all kinds--one woman's relationship with her father reveals a host of other truths about family and divorce, about tradition and what it does or doesn't mean, and ultimately about what lasts--what survives the failures of love. Eloquently, wittily and compellingly structured, told and scored.

Comment on piece: The Valentine 1955


A pivotal moment, a sudden ending.

The Valentine, 1955 leads up to a perfect pivotal moment between two children as race and culture drive a wedge between them. It is a great moment, an important moment to understand, but then the piece just drops us there. I would have liked a little more time just to digest what had happened. If this was played on the radio, I can't imagine what you would say to follow up to those last words.

Comment on piece: The Allure of Karaoke Singing

User image

Review of The Allure of Karaoke Singing

This is a listener-friendly fun piece that makes a pretty good case for Karaoke. How did THEY know how easily I dismissed the activity (without ever having set foot in a Karaoke bar)?
But NOW I get it. Anybody who can hit that high note in Jay and the American's Cara Mia deserves a spot on your station.

Caption: PRX default User image

Pop Vultures #5: Nirvana again? Yawn! (deleted)

I think Kate should get over her teenage celebrity crushes and move on to more mature subjects... She's the kind of voice I want to hear hosting ATC!
So as a member of the "young" public radio audience, I do NOT want to rehash old debates about an album I stopped listening to in 1992. (If I did, I'd read Spin instead of turning on my local public radio station.) I want to hear something new - and maybe some insight into the classics.
8 half-hour shows and I've heard all these songs before. Public radio is supposed to introduce you to new people, places, things, ideas that you otherwise might not come across. Play me something new!

Comment on piece: No Email from Oaxaca

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of No Email from Oaxaca

It’s a window onto such a small, mundane moment, but still, within it, there is a feeling of an abyss being crossed. The reading style is quiet. It doesn’t over dramatize and over-reach. It is personal in the best sense, in that it communicates a sense of Adam’s personality. I hope I’m not spoiling anything by quoting to you the last line of the piece. I don’t think that I am: “He was a nice man but if I saw him again I probably wouldn’t have recognized him or his wife.” How often does a story on the radio end that way? I’d say not often, but stories end like that all the time in real life. It’s nice to hear something like that owed up to. It is honest and well written with echoes of Scott Carrier. It isn't newsy and there is no grand point, but it does make you feel less alone in the city.

Comment on piece: :60: Peepers

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of :60: Peepers

I just had to listen to this several times. It stirs something within you on a primordial level. It’s undeniably effecting. Hearing this in your car on your way to work might have the power to make you feel lonely for something hard to explain. Nature, maybe. Anyway, the wistful feeling of loss is remarkable. And that it’s a minute that represents two weeks of work gives it an added force. It is like a tightly constructed haiku that has the strength of a sledgehammer. By the end, when all the sounds come together, it is symphonic. Oddly, it feels like the end of a narrative arc of some sort, even though it is wordless. It’s alarming.

User image

Review of L. H. Karaoke Lounge (deleted)

Having recently produced a piece on karaoke singing myself, I found this interesting and informative. Ben seemed to interview all the right people who had thoughful insights to share, and I loved the non-Vietnamese guy who prefers singing in Vietnamese. I also got a good sense of what the place is like.

User image

Review of Pop Vultures #8: Guilty Pleasures (deleted)

This show has improved so much since the last time I heard it. They have finally figured out how to make it not-confusing when people come in and out for no particular reason.

Comment on piece: No Email from Oaxaca

User image

Review of Change

I really like the personal commentary in this piece. I think the producer makes some valid points (Selling nick-nacks via FedEx) and tells a good narrative.

Somehwere along the 4 or so minutes however it just seems to go a little flat, and then ends with no real point being made. Also the hushed tones and dreamy music don't help it in my opinion.

I would like to hear this on the radio in a slightly version.

Comment on piece: The Future is San Francisco

User image

Review of The Future is San Francisco

An engaging five-minute commentary on San Francisco, by a writer who moved there as an eleven-year-old Vietnamese refugee thirty years ago. His ideas on what is good about the city (and, by extension, what would be good for all of us) are skillfully constructed and well delivered. He does the "public radio commentary" tradition proud. It ties in nicely with the latest news from the city by the bay, but it is really and evergreen.

User image

Review of L. H. Karaoke Lounge (deleted)

Another strong piece from the Salt alum and the mean streets of Portland, Maine. The L. H. Karaoke Lounge shares its storefront with a pawnshop, a travel agency, a Vietnamese restaurant and a tailor but on weekend nights it becomes a popular hangout for Vietnamese crooners. If art imitates life, then karaoke imitates the life of Asian immigrants. I think many of the Salt pieces are deserving of airtime outside of the Maine listening area. A Salt series or a Salt special (maybe paired with a two-way with Salt radio director Rob Rosenthal) could be a terrific one-off idea for a station interested in highlighting how radio gets made.