All Comments


Comment on piece: White House Tapes: The President Calling

User image

Review of White House Tapes: The President Calling

Take the ability to eavesdrop on three potent presidents, stir in a fast-moving, context-providing narrative, spice with insightful commentary from a shelf full of thoughtful historians, sprinkle with smidges of fine music, and sit back for a fascinating, engaging, amusing, and instructive hour of great radio. sl

Comment on piece: Two-Minute Danger Theater 01: The Voice "Death Stalks at Midnight" Ch 1

User image

Review of Two-Minute Danger Theater 01: The Voice "Death Stalks at Mid

Well, I listened to a few episodes here and here. I think there is a general disdain for updated radio drama on public radio these days, which is a real shame. There should be more entertaining options than what public radio is now... primarily NPR, Jazz or Classical music. (yawn) CBC still has some radio drama thrown in, a lot of which isn't as fun to listen to as this.

Sampling just one episode doesn't really do this series justice. Maybe that's the way a listener might listen, but they might also get hooked in and want to follow the storyline and be sure to tune in regularly. This could be a useful pledge vehicle under the right circumstances. I found the radio dramas on the Rider's Radio Theatre quite addicting. That was a wonderful show, yet I'm sure it had pretty poor carriage. What a shame.

The pacing in this series is fast and humor does have to be spelled out to work on radio. Producers do have to be careful about this. Maybe it would be good to include some host copy to assist in the setup and would tie the stations in more.

However, I don't fault anyone for demanding attention from the listener. We should try to do that more often (of course, without the expectation that they will pick up on every subtle nuance). Yes, people use radio as background at times, but isn?t it also ironic that classical music?s highest listening hours (typically in the afternoon) are when it can pledge the worst? More listeners don't always equal more pledges, especially if listeners are used to tuning out at that time.

BTW, to compare this type of thing to what Tom Keith does isn't really fair. Tom Keith is a folly guy with a big budget and lots of help. I assume they don't have that kind of a budget. Despite that, it is quite well done and the acting and production are better than I have heard in a lot of other modern radio drama pieces.

I would like to hear some folly sound effects rather than relying on CDs entirely. Though I know that takes a long time to prepare and pull off. I produced similar material in the past with out-of-date music libraries and those effects can be hilarious as well. Modern sound libraries are sometimes too slick to be funny.

Hey, I give anyone credit for trying something brave and would like to see that spirit encouraged in American public broadcasting. Two minutes isn't too much to dedicate to this module, though I can already hear the excuses that many PDs will make. It might be interesting to see if longer segments (once a week) would be more useable within a program. Plus weekends are when more of the wackier stuff is typically heard.

Comedy is tough to pull off, especially on the radio. Nit picking it is the easy part. Who else has the guts to stand up and try?

Comment on piece: Primary Participation

User image

Review of Primary Participation

Interesting report, well recorded and well-chosen tape makes you feel like you’re sitting right there, jawing with the locals. A good warm-up piece for election season. sl

Comment on piece: A Cook's Notebook: Wonderland Chicken Stock

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of A Cook's Notebook: Wonderland Chicken Stock

Chef Ali Berlow offers an engaging insight into how food and cooking fit into her life. An ingredient, process or finished dish - she encourages us to savour it all, and spend just a bit more time thinking about the food we put in our mouths. It's personal and quirky, unusual and interesting. As a monologue it does its job, but I would like to hear her 'placed', not in the studio, but somewhere relevant.

Comment on piece: Singing in St. Andrews

User image

Review of Singing in St. Andrews

This is a cute (but not sappy) vignette about simple and universal expressions of love. The couple are instantly likeable and this short interview creates a vivid portrait. This would make for a nice drop-in almost anytime, especially around Valentine's Day, Sweetest Day, etc.
I'd like to see the narration stripped out of the interview itself. Once the narration describes the kissing and blushing, I realized a didn't need a narration anymore--I just want to hear them. Everything the internal narration says after the basic introduction (ending about :35 into piece) is either covered elsewhere or redundant to the interviewees' comments. I listened to it a few times, mentally edited out the voice over, and I think it would make the portrait even stronger. Further, I must admit that I agree--the bookends of "Amazing Grace" feel a little cliche here. Bagpipe music isn't mentioned in the piece--so why is it there?

Comment on piece: Jehovah's Witness

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Jehovah's Witness

This radio journal expressed a very moving and intimate reflection of a subgroup of youths today. The author paces her piece in a way that draws the listener deeply into her world. I found her view of the lack of expressive love shown towards her by her mother a sad example of the interwoven structure of organized religion. As a writer her piece was straight ward and direct without allowing the listener to drift off. As a journalist, her use of her mother’s reading of a pray (in her native Spanish) unmasked the ‘otherness’ that is often associated with unfamiliar religious groups than our own. In fact this piece is no less radio journal than a testament to the social ramifications of religious blindness that permeates throughout the world. Great piece of social radio.

Comment on piece: Singing in St. Andrews

User image

Review of Singing in St. Andrews

Everything is lovely here, but you don't want Amazing Grace as the bookends. Yeah, on the bagpipes, it says Scotland, but a dog on a leash with bagpipes will say Scotland. What's wanted here is an unknown tune -- mysterious and haunting. The rest is absolutely delightful.

Comment on piece: Fresh Pond Trees

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Fresh Pond Trees

Beautifully recorded. Unconventional even by PubRad standards. Might be a tough play on the air as there's so much space. The voice-over is a bit directive for such a transendentalist mood. It's tough to beat mother nature at her best.

Comment on piece: Navajo Pentacostal

User image

Review of Navajo Pentacostal [Scott Carrier]

Good listening with more sound and less 'splain'n. Dig the reggae rhythms played on a Fender Stratocaster by a Navaho preacher. Ahh...revenge of the place documentarians who return to tip the balance from cause and effect, point / counter-point narrative journalism. Thank goodness for Scott Carrier's ears-wide-open nonlinearity.

Comment on piece: Meaning of Life Show: Episode 1 - Music

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Meaning of Life Show: Episode 1 - Music

I REALLY enjoyed this piece! It has all the right elements of a great radio piece- very funny at times, as well as quite deep, compelling, and interesting. You can't wait to hear what's coming next. So many different types of stories, yet all woven around one grad topic- spirituality in music. I would recommend this show to ANYONE with an interest in music or the meaning of life, which I'd think is pretty much all of us.

Comment on piece: A Trip to the Dentist

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of A Trip to the Dentist [Larry Massett]

Wonderfully textural production with layers of sound evoking pure primal connection to the subject matter. The litany of buckles for the chicklets, the pendelous rhythms - has as hypnotic an effect on the listener as on the patient. We recall laughing at the start of the piece, then apprehension, now a narcotic effect comes over us we too are drifting... in and out of procedures... did we feel a certain sharpness arcing through our jaws? Somehow we're not reassured by the knowledge that our dentist has a background in arts & crafts. The triumphal finish has us re-evaluating our initial apprehension. Great stuff!

Comment on piece: A Trip to the Dentist

User image

Review of A Trip to the Dentist [Larry Massett]

I don't know why I am listening to this, because I am between deep-cleaning sessions myself. I can understand why this came from Neurotica, though.

So why am I saying this is a lot of fun? Because by listening to this I hope I will be able to endure my upcoming procedures.

Great writing.

The only thing I would have loved is the one-sided conversational techniques of dental types everywhere. Only after your mouth is filled with equipment do they ask you about your day. And how can they understand what you say? Maybe it's time for a sequel, Larry.

Comment on piece: Street Music

User image

Review of Street Music

Great recordings and soundscape. Loved the movement through places and people. Felt like a personal tour of Bologna. Braider has a great voice for radio. Would have liked to have heard his commentary in first person rather than reportage. His voice could lend itself to the more personal approach. Still this piece would be an assett to any magazine program. Good work!

Comment on piece: Cambridge Bay Soundscape

User image

Review of Cambridge Bay Soundscape

Beautifully recorded and mixed sound. Perfection. Nothing less. Fenner created an exquisite audio landscape with this piece. I want to go there now!

Comment on piece: Cambridge Bay Soundscape

User image

Review of Cambridge Bay Soundscape

Master soundscape artist Victoria Fenner proves you don't need narrative to tell place stories. I'm blown away by the shear luxury of hearing 7:47 of Arctic Circle life. There's a gentle native expansiveness and unhurried emptiness occasionally stamped by the artist as she plays with and in the sound environment. Broadcast this and help audiences learn to hear as babies again. Transcendent naive / outsider / folk music ending - beautiful as a setting arctic sun.

Comment on piece: My Family Tis of Thee

User image

Review of My Family Tis of Thee

Macsai wields her wand of humour with great dexterity making her points irrefutably dead on. Also she's got that way of connecting the oddest things that infuse you with a fresh way of looking. This is a good essay for Democracy theme but also other times of political introspection...4th of July???

Comment on piece: Copper River Journey

User image

Review of Copper River Journey

The telling of this river trip skillfully winds through information on the environment, development threats, and the poignant knowledge that this is near where the Exxon Valdez ran aground. We’re given the personalities of the rafting group and of the river itself, brought close-in to the richness of the experience. The producer confesses his fear of what he aptly calls eco-mysticism, but even if you feel the piece veers toward those shores, the joy and wonder of the rafters grabs you. And I ask, who can resist the sound of rushing water? sl

User image

Review of Democracy In The Age Of Dubya (deleted)

Predisposed to finding Al Franken right-on hilarious, this reviewer is utterly biased. Funny, pointed, angry, astute words. Let him rip, he rips. Great stuff. Confession: wrote this review in the first three minutes, but only in order to sit back and happily listen. sl

Comment on piece: call to canada

User image

Review of call to canada

This piece was the one that inspired me to feature Your Radio Nightlight on my own public radio program (Invisible Ink). Benjamen's nervous rambling to the Canadian immigration official is hilarious and engaging. I also greatly enjoyed the beginning of the segment, which uses the telephone menu system to set up the story. Listen to how quickly Walker presses the buttons in response to the menu options. It's a great storytelling technique. For me, the real appeal is that it is a funny story that is underscored by a very tangible sense of despair and hopelessness. Just so this isn't too fawning a review, it is a pretty loose piece (it's rambling by design) and could probably get the point across with a minute or two shaved off the TRT. That's a minor observation compared to how much fun I had listening to it.

Comment on piece: Piazza San Marco

User image

Review of Piazza San Marco

Bells are there to be recorded, and thanks to Dmae, we are getting bells we should have heard on pubrad a long time ago. I would have given a kid a Euro to rattle the pigeons -- it's amazing the noise a thousand flying rats can make. And I would have found space for the moving clock on the west (?) side of the piazza. Still, the bells are beautiful -- worth every moment.