All Comments


Comment on piece: Grand Old Flag

User image

Review of Grand Old Flag

Nicely-paced and narrated look at an emotional and politically complex matter. While Southern states struggle to resolve their flag conflicts, the report touches on a larger notion: whether voter referendums are always in the public's best interest. Given the 2003 Californa Governor's recall brouhaha (and expense), it is an issue worth exploring.

Comment on piece: The Next Generation: Democracy on Campus

User image

Review of The Next Generation: Democracy on Campus

This University of Michigan centered report provides a useful update on the current campus political scene. We hear about conservative activists, anti-war, affirmative action, etc. We hear from a small but well-spoken and diverse group of students. I would have liked to hear from a few more, but mostly because I was interested, not because there wasn't enough range. For those distant from campus life, or college kids, a reminder that student life can be about more than studying and consuming. sl

Comment on piece: "Oil Slick: Bechtel, Halliburton, and the White House"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of "Oil Slick: Bechtel, Halliburton, and the White House"

This was an interesting piece that covers a long series of events during the last 30 years involving many of our current political leaders. Although some will try to label this as a biased political conspiracy theory, one of it's strengths is that it plots a long series of events that cannot be construed as anything but a deliberate effort.

It's definitely worth a listen, although I felt that the announcer lacked a certain level of urgency in the delivery.

Comment on piece: Democracy Yes, Change No

User image

Review of Democracy Yes, Change No

There is absolutely no reason why a station in Boston should air this piece. But what if there were numerous pieces from all across the US of A that addressed similar questions -- say, people near the military reservation on Cape Cod, where water quality has fallen subject to forces beyond their ballot box?

A good, solid story, well told. A potentially interesting use of the PRX model to provide new definitions for the "community" in community radio.

Comment on piece: Democracy, American-Style: "You're Always Running"

User image

Review of Democracy, American-Style: "You're Always Running"

Simple vox pop format, could be useful in stimulating discussion during democracy-themed call in shows. Real people with real unfiltered opinions.

Comment on piece: "Oil Slick: Bechtel, Halliburton, and the White House"

User image

Review of "Oil Slick: Bechtel, Halliburton, and the White House"

This is a revealing investigation into the actions of several corporations with close connections to Republican officials. It is a comprehensive indictment of successive Republican administrations, regarding their involvement with the former Iraqi regime and its oil resources. It offers a historical perspective to the current post-war situation in Iraq, and is packed full of information that would make your average democrat's blood boil. HW

Comment on piece: Anatomy of a Wrongful Conviction

User image

Review of Anatomy of a Wrongful Conviction

This is a compelling investigation of a man who spent 10 years in prison for a homicide that he didn't commit . It's investigative, it's dramatic, it's full of great interviews, unsettling realities and it's beautifully edited.

This could be aired on All things Considered, This American Life (although the aesthetics aren't exactly TALish--it shares their sensibilities) Weekend edition or it could be broadcast as part of any series or special that addresses the maladies of the US justice system, socio economic injustices and/or racism.

(Apparently this has a PART II, "Exoneration," so let's hope it is also uploaded to PRX.)

Comment on piece: Democracy, American-Style: "Question Everything"

User image

Review of Democracy, American-Style: "Question Everything"

refreshing voice - the premise of this series is a good one although not every one who answers the question can be likeable or engaging but this guy is real.
vm

Comment on piece: Democracy, American-Style: "I Voted for the Dead Man"

User image

Review of Democracy, American-Style: "I Voted for the Dead Man"

nice premise - amusing yet provocative nugget off the street. Perfect M/E material

vm

Comment on piece: What is Poetry?

User image

Review of What is Poetry?

good evergreen oasis.
Interesting mix of more current music with a vocal cadence of the past. Really thougtful. unusual but not overly - easy to hear in the middle of most live programming.

vm

Comment on piece: Never Too Young

User image

Review of Never Too Young

It's always great to hear young voices on the radio - she's quite polished for her age - a refreshing spot in the midst of political loftiness.

vm

Comment on piece: Azar Nafisi interview

User image

Review of Azar Nafisi interview

The general lack of understanding North
Americans have of other cultures, and our current, oh, what is the right word? connection to the Middle East, makes this a very useful and compelling conversation. Sandip Roy's questions are perhaps different from those a woman would ask –– he concentrates on the politics, lands less heavily on women's issues, but his questions are thoughtful and stimulating. Azar is articulate, eloquent, and covers the women's ground she wants covered regardless of the question. And she has a lovely voice and laugh. Now I must read that book!

sl

Comment on piece: The Power of One

User image

Review of The Power of One

Quirky piece about quirky politicians in a, you- guessed-it, quirky place. Unless you're up on Alaskan politics, it'll be hard to do more than hang on as he rapidly fingers his way through this string of worry beads, but some images stand out. The point is to encourage the listener to VOTE, and to amuse them on the way to the message, and that it does.
sl

Comment on piece: Democracy, American-Style: "Wanted: Smarter Citizens"

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Democracy, American-Style: "Wanted: Smarter Citizens"

One of a series of person-on-the street interviews on the subject of democracy. Nice vox pop quality, short and pithy, could be sprinkled throughout a democracy-themed talk/call in show to promote discussion.

Comment on piece: Convenient Democracy

User image

Review of Convenient Democracy

Interesting survey of current attempts to end the 40-year decline in voter participation levels and get registered voters to the polls. Fine range of voices (accents, energy levels, opinions), and information. Narrative zips right along. Makes me think about ways to get my non-voting acquaintances off their bums and into the voting booths.

sl

Comment on piece: The Ears Have It! [excerpt]

User image

Review of The Ears Have It! [excerpt]

Wee playful tribute to our very favorite art form: audio! Everyone should air this everywhere. Read so fast it's over almost before you absorb it, and I enjoyed it more the second hearing, so maybe everyone should air this everywhere twice.

sl

Comment on piece: Lessons From the Fall: A Losing Candidate's Reflections

User image

Review of So You Want to be a Politician?

Personable voices offering sometimes amusing take on first-time candidates experience of the electoral process. Good, quick piece, nicely reported.

sl

Comment on piece: The Best Democracy Money can Buy

User image

Review of The Best Office Money can Buy

Basic report on the issue of self-financed candidates. Not the liveliest voices, and the sound feels a little compressed, but that's not overly distracting. Good to air in a big election year.
sl

Comment on piece: Kids Corner: Youthful Vision

User image

Review of Kids Corner: Youthful Vision

Excellent for explaining the elements of the Constitution for kids AND adults - some surprises but great for learning in lieu of "studying" the Constitution. Especially good for co-listening with kids - No dumbing down, but keeps it unencumbered without overly erudite tone, more like a favorite semi-hip elementary teacher. My son would definitely listen perhaps while drawing a picture of Thomas Jefferson...

vm

Comment on piece: Welcome to Redistricting Hell

User image

Review of Welcome to Redistricting Hell

Given current redistricting conflicts across the country, this timely and timeless report is a useful overview of the issue. No music, just straight ahead narrative with various voices laying out their concerns about race, representation and voter apathy. A good piece to air prior to local voter registration deadlines.

sl