All Comments


Comment on piece: UK Bootlegs and Mashups

User image

Review of UK Bootlegs and Mashups

A well-informed look at a music production style emerging from the underground. Musical samples are used to illustrate the technique discussed. Accessible and cutting-edge at the same time. Sonorous dialog between American and English dialect speakers. With an appropriate segue, this piece could air next to a hard news story about intellectual property, file sharing or celebrity image-ownership. Air this now and boost your station's hipness factor.

Comment on piece: Dead Animal Man

User image

Review of Dead Animal Man

I remember this piece from way back. It holds up. Interestingly, it has a kind of NPR style that still sounds like NPR, while Ira's style has changed quite a bit. The most intimate moment is the conversation between Ira and the Animal Man at the end. I hope Ira will put up other early stuff like this. I remember a good one about a Halloween scary theme park. -JA

Comment on piece: Profile of an Accidental Shooting

User image

Review of Profile of an Accidental Shooting

This is a strong piece in every way. The voicing and writing are clear, the interviews intimate, and the subject compelling. Even though the central event occurred a few years ago, the subject remains important and the text here on PRX gives a current context for any station that might want to pick it up. If you were doing a series on gun control or safety, this piece would be a strong addition. - J.A.

Comment on piece: Fair Pay for a Day's Work

User image

Review of Fair Pay for a Day's Work

National media often give short shrift to labor issues, so this is a welcome piece of work. Good range of voices, context, information, and detail. We get a real feeling for the issues at hand and for why the union-immigrant partnership is so crucial to the labor movement. sl

Comment on piece: Stories1st: Temple in Taiwan

User image

Review of Temple in Taiwan

Wonderfully big and sound-rich stereo ambience contrasted with intimate voice-over. Beautifully present sense of place free from cause & effect storytelling linearity.

Comment on piece: What it Takes to be a Good Citizen

User image

Review of What it Takes to be a Good Citizen

Interesting take on what it means to be a good citizen. The producer profiles two expressive women with very different priorities. A gentle visit with people like us – lots of demands on our time, genuine concern about government, but different ways of investing in society. sl

Comment on piece: Life Stories - Jobs: Teaching ("Educating Esme')

User image

Review of Life Stories - Jobs: Teaching ("Educating Esme')

Beautifully produced journey through a new teacher’s first year in an urban school. Esme’s frank thoughts and vivid descriptions are well served by her personable delivery, whether imitating students, other adults, or herself. She’s a great guide to her own experience – good company, a wise and generous observer, an engaging speaker. The music accents are superb. sl

Comment on piece: interview with Bend it like Beckham filmmaker

User image

Review of interview with Bend it like Beckham filmmaker

Entertaining, lively conversation with the director and screenwriter o f this popular film, along with audio clips. They talk about the origin, meaning, and process, as well as audience response. I haven’t seen this movie, but now I must. sl

Comment on piece: Be Connected Documentary on Emerging Energy Technologies

User image

Review of Be Connected Documentary on Emerging Energy Technologies

Well-paced tour hither and yon through new and alternative energy technologies. Explanations are simple and clear enough for even an utterly non-science oriented listener, such as myself, to tag along without brain strain. Lots to learn here. sl

User image

Review of Who Is Harvey Pekar? (deleted)

Oh Harvey, we love your whimsical, unique, observant self. Harvey makes us look at the world through his eyes, and it’s like when you walk out of a great movie and suddenly the world looks different…Go listen, and let your eyes open wide. Terrific production. sl

Comment on piece: Wu Man - Pipa player

User image

Review of Wu Man - Pipa player

Lovely portrait-in-brief of this musician, in her own words, scored with gorgeous examples of pipa music. Good refresh-the-senses piece. sl

Comment on piece: Housekeeping: Behind the Scenes

User image

Review of Housekeeping: Behind the Scenes

"...my only negative comment is about the sound quality, there should be someway of dampening the echo of the room."

I wholeheartedly disagree. If everything sounded like we were in the studio all the time, it would be pretty boring. (Not to mention that public radio really lacks good monster truck ads.) I really don't understand the desire for many in public radio to make things sound dead (soundproofed) or the constant complaining about phone sound. Isn't the content more important? In this case, the echo helps set the listener in the bathroom so it provides a transition.

My only complaint (this is pure opinion) is that I'm not sure what a song about a tall girl from Brazil other than the line "...she just doesn't see.." has to do with anything about North American hotels. I'm actually in favor of talking over song lyrics, but I do believe that they should be relevant to the story otherwise it can be distracting. I would have put a variety of music underneath. Maybe I'm missing the point. It's been known to happen.

Comment on piece: Housekeeping: Behind the Scenes

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Housekeeping: Behind the Scenes

I enjoyed the show, my only negative comment is about the sound quality, there should be someway of dampening the echo of the room.

Comment on piece: Cyber Democracy and Civic Discourse

User image

Review of Cyber Democracy and Civic Discourse

The potential power of on-line political discussion is real, but as this piece tells it, unbalanced, and in its infancy. Food for thought. sl

Comment on piece: Sisters

User image

Review of Sisters

A lovely, reflective visit with a series of sisters of different generations underscored with lovely piano music. A good piece to drop in any old where you have a few minutes to fill. Refreshing. sl

Comment on piece: On Deaf Ears

User image

Review of On Deaf Ears

We’ve got polls up the wazoo. This brief, well-paced piece touches on some of the concerns people and politicians in Utah have on the way to casting their votes. The same concerns exist nationwide. sl

Comment on piece: WNYC's Fishko Files: What Can I Say: Culture of Patriotism and Dissent

User image

Review of What Can I Say: Culture of Patriotism and Dissent

Thoughtful, very interesting and well-produced journey through specific moments in the culture of patriotism and dissent. Interviews and tape of a variety of entertainment figures and observers take us back in time and up to the present, reminding us that freedom of expression must never be taken for granted. Plus, it's a kick to hear some of the old bits followed by reflections on how the humor was received. sl

Comment on piece: Triangle, The Fire That Changed America

User image

Review of Triangle, The Fire That Changed America

Very interesting conversation about a pivotal moment in U.S. history. This horrific fire fueled the first major domestic policy changes of 20th Century, all enacted during the New Deal. And until 9/11, this was the most devastating largescale NY City tragedy on record. It's timely for that reason and because of the current administration's attempts to retract so much of what the New Deal accomplished. That it's a phoner is unfortunate, despite being well-recorded, just because of the grating-ness of phone line recording. Vogel asks good questions and allows the author to fully answer without jumping in to move him along, and that's a good thing. sl

Comment on piece: How to Sing the Star-Spangled Banner


Review of How to Sing the Star-Spangled Banner

Who knew that trick about hitting the high note? Short, but a pleasant and surprising little break from the norm.

Comment on piece: The Pol Walk


Review of The Pol Walk

"The Pol Walk" is a delightful and refreshing reminder of someting we too often forget about democracy: that it's supposed to involve regular people. The rhythm of the piece serves its message well, and the sound behind it places the listener firmly on the door-knocking trail with the candidate. Would be a wonderful break from traditional campaign coverage.