Comments by Marjorie Van Halteren

Comment for "Crossing East: Raising Cane - Program Three"

User image

Review of Crossing East: Raising Cane - Program Three

CROSSING EAST - Raising Cane

You hear about Driveway Moments, but do you ever hear about Naive Moments? That's when, while listening to a radio program, you face up to the fact that you don't know a whole lot about something all around you. For example, I know nothing very substantial about Hawaii as a place where people have forged a history. This program features so much dedicated scholarship, stories and colorful detail that it has required a multitude of voices, actors mixing gently in with interview material and other sound. And yes, this is one of those projects with lots of people to acknowledge at the end - but the beautiful variety of the names in the credits somehow themselves make up a kind of poem testifying to this important effort.

These moments - of a history hardly mentioned in school or few Hollywood movies - these are the moments that public broadcasting owes its audience, I feel.

PS I also know very little about the history and contributions of Asian Americans in general. How about you? Why is that? Maybe I ought to listen to some other programs in the series.

Comment

User image

Review of What's in a Song (deleted)

In the piece called, "Bells of Ireland," Spring is here! This is a lovely little mix of gardening, Ireland, and the music peeking through - the kind of singing that makes my throat involuntarily pop open in song - and though the details are wonderful - a grandmother who made hollyhock dolls: bells resonating everywhere! - I yearned for alittle more time to hear the music itself - and enjoy the crystalline voice of the singer. Would it be a problem for the piece to be longer?

Comment for "Donald Justice: In Pursuit of the Ideal"

User image

Review of Donald Justice: In Pursuit of the Ideal

The range of eloquent interviews with friends and colleagues about the late poet Donald Justice that this team has collected have come together to form a program that is gently passionate but sprawling. I can well understand how very important this artist is, especially to Iowa - but I had the feeling that the (many) producers of this piece just couldn't bear to leave anything out (or perhaps they disagreed!), and that this keeps the program from finding a strong thread to pull the listener along. That, and a rather odd decision to often play classical musical behind the speakers, no matter what they're talking about, very quietly, as though to suggest they're all in the same living room with the stereo playing. Listeners are going to have to be very, very interested in poetry and poets to make it through to the high point, which is the work itself. The time spent on people saying he was brilliant, and talented, and special far outweigh the time we get treated to work itself (which we in fact do, and very nicely at the end) Insiders might think Justice poems are something understood, that they're known everyone who might be listening. If only that were true!

Comment for "The Heidi Chronicles" (deleted)

User image

Review of The Heidi Chronicles (deleted)

This is what I consider a real opportunity, to hear this play from the "best seat in the house" in front of your radio, beautifully acted and directed. Yes, I am disappointed by the lack of contemporary plays exploiting the unique brilliance of audio, and I do have reservations about the idea that play after play can be recycled for audio as though the other aspects of the original medium didn't really matter anyway (what does that say about these plays as theatre?) - but so often they do work wonderfully, and LA Theatre Works does a great job. This production is important obviously because we just lost Wendy Wasserstein, so long before her time - but also because of the times in which she has been lost. There is a moment in the first act where Scoop says to Heidi, "you're the one that all this is going to affect. Get out there." It is now 40 years later. Where are the young women, whom all this is going to affect? Plus ?a change. Heidi says, "I hope our daughters never feel like this." Do they? Young women, have a listen and let us know!

Comment for "Stagefright"

User image

Review of Stagefright

Lovely - the voice of a woman - which the reporter steps back to let us hear -and some well-deliverd thoughts about life down the road - for Edith - and for us all. Quite simply a little gem.

Comment for "Stick Poke Scrape Dump"

User image

Review of Stick Poke Scrape Dump

This is an unusual torrent of words, at once gentle and sharp. It very much needs a live, one-sentence intro saying it's a poetic description of this job that the producer/reader vividly (and passionately!) recalls from his youth - this mature, mellow, radio-sounding voice does not sound the voice of a person in this situation - but if you can place the scene, it's good to go, and would work nicely for any station wanting to observe April with poetry - and do! do! Poetic writing especially for the radio is so precious!

Comment for "Jazz Inspired - Mark Murphy" (deleted)

User image

Review of Jazz Inspired - Mark Murphy (deleted)

The first time I heard Mark Murphy sing I was a young woman living all alone in a Manhattan apartment in the 70's with a radio that would supply jazz 24/7 with some real discoveries coming out at night - and I went nuts. I bought the vinyl and bought a single ticket to Carnegie Hall, an evening I'll never forget.

Apparently it's a voice that either you appreciate like a Shakespeare monolog and will follow anywhere, or a performance that annoys you subtly in the way it breaks the rules. He discusses all that in this relaxed hour, which I listened to twice. He meanders. She interrupts with bursts of laughter. He's dead honest and brilliant. And she's so confident but sweet, and giving, they're having a ball. He sings. Lord, he sings.

The production is very good - it's not done exactly as I would for example. Maybe I'd bring in the music in different parts, not sneak it in THERE, chose a couple of different cuts maybe, trim this, add what? but SOOO what!

In this program they talk a lot about rhythms, and breaking the rules, in an intriguing, inside-outside kind of way. They're talking about jazz of course, but they could be talking about anything - even radio.

Comment for "Border Radio: The Big Jukebox in the Sky"

User image

Review of Border Radio: The Great Big Jukebox in the Sky

This is a pulsating tumbleweed tornado swooping through the ether - it reverberates exactly with the bygone days of driving through the Southern night twisting the dial hoping to hook something GOOD. No disappointment here -the amount of music, sound and good times that have been crocheted up into this mere hour is awesome. How many biscuits can I eat? More - my New Year's diet is history!

One comment - make sure stations have a very simple intro to give listeners a heads up that this fever dream is coming their way - like, "straight from Austin Texas, recorded live over an evening."

The extra tone I select is: exciting!

Comment for "End of the Rope" (deleted)

User image

Review of End of the Rope (deleted)

END OF THE ROPE
There IS intelligent life on the radio comedy planet! Lots of it, in fact - and I love this host's sparkling, clear voice and her performances. The sound effects are virtuoso - another "lost" art being recaptured. The segment of a pair of old coots failing to demount their horses is accompanied by an excellent performance by horse and kit. The retro 50's segment is an opportunity to showcase the delicate art of mouth sounds. HOWEVER, the rubrick," the lighter side of women's issues," does not work for me at all. Several marvellous pieces seemed to have been shoe-horned in there - it is not purely a programming issue, which I don't pretend to take on - it's simply making me listen to the thing in the wrong way. I could have missed what they're really doing, as described above. Is it because the word "issue" could be one of the unfunniest words in the English language, so unfunny that it defies parody? All I know is, darlin', you and your crew deserve a SHOW! Just come out and say MY SHOW!

Comment for "Orchestral Paris (Compact Discoveries Program 80)"

User image

Review of Orchestral Paris

Fred Flaxman makes a good companion for the pleasures of classical music. He's knowledgable with a light touch. This is, quite naturally, a needledrop show, with, this time, quite long needledrops - also natural, because of the nature of the works. In reviewing this piece, I find myself face to face with the odd fact that I personally don't care for grand orchestral works - even Gerswin. But it's pretty much a question of playlist, isn't it? - and if this one suits (as well it might), then Flaxman's your man. He's got quite a selection on offer from program to program.

Comment for "What's the Word? Famous Love Letters"

User image

Review of What's the Word? Famous Love Letters

When's the last time you wrote or received a REAL love letter? Long, long before e-mail, people actually pulled out pen and paper and wrote important, life-altering words - and this program has found three very famous and stunnng examples of unique relationships. A refined offering for Valentine's Day.

Comment for "A Shortcut To The Mountaintop"

User image

Review of A Shortcut To The Mountaintop

A half-hour of stirring words and very fitting, pleasurable music - Peter has chosen a great sampling of King's speeches that are definitely NOT going to be the same ones that will heard on every TV newscast in the nation in this season. You're thinking, he said THAT? and oh, yes yes he certainly did. We mustn't ever forget. Here's to Dr. and Mrs. King, forever.

Comment for "Passion" (deleted)

User image

Review of Passion (deleted)

I have become a podcast listener to the program Open Source, and a fan. Of all the engaging subjects I have heard so far, the discussion on Candy (passion series) was 100% addicting. Start anyone talking about this in the context of memory, hope, dreams and desires, and they will not stop!

So many of these programs deserve a five rating, that's only one. One might say that the internet has no gatekeepers - and then one might contend that gatekeepers always appear anyway. This lyrical, swinging gate called Christopher Lydon (with team) provides a frame that is dilligent, open, focused and curious.

Comment for "A Poem Lovely as a Tree"

User image

Review of A Poem Lovely as a Tree

Lively little left-handed hommage to the famous poem - blossoming out with bright archival clips - the last interviewee, a poet, says it aptly - Joyce Kilmer has lodged that sliver in there pretty deep. Is there a National Tree Day? Well, declare one!

Comment for "Retiring with Dahlias"

User image

Review of Retiring with Dahlias

Here is an interview with a WWII veteran that sequ?s from his story during the war into his current passion, his colorful dahlias. A charming idea that intrigued me quite a lot - and in fact, the interview is full of delicate moments and potential juxtapositions. Here is where I feel bound to give the opinion that I wish it were more imaginatively produced. The interview is evenly edited with a kind of generic guitar picking slipped onto the beginning and end - his speech being slow and measured (normal considering his age) this music does little to underscore, and little is done in the production to use the ebb and flow, peaks and valleys of the imagery. There are lovely details here, especially in the end, his comments. (An interview nicely conducted.) I'd be delighted to listen again to this one, re-worked with a compositional mindset.

Comment for "He Has No Time"

User image

Review of He Has No Time

Oh, oh, oh I know what he means! I was delighted by the energy and the layered style, and the confessions of the young man - just wait 'til you're my age, sonny, it doesn't get any better. Lasso it in now! The story at the end about Samuel Beckett on his deathbed, apocryphal or not, made me howl out loud. At the end I heard that it was a tri-state effort - sending that sound around - great! but watch those voice levels/recordings over that saturated music. PS Israel Horowitz is THE Israel Horowitz, famous playwright, and NOT just dad of Adam!!! (chee!)

Comment for "A Shortcut Through 2005"

User image

Review of A Shortcut Through 2005

Lovely collage of music and actuality cuts - Peter's been making this style of piece for a long time - and it's a subtle, enjoyable kind of radio - the kind that stretches out and introduces the listener to surprising music, all the time peppering it with "whazzat?" sound - you know what it is - or do you? A nice programming choice for stations that enjoy mixing music with alitte edge.

Comment for "Keeping Secrets"

User image

Review of Keeping Secrets

A piece about one of the more mysterious sides of random communicaton - including the internet, which, honestly, is normally absolutely everything BUT mysterious. Aaron Henkin reports on this interesting project involving postcards and secrets and folks like you and me - at the center of it is this rather compassionate character for whom the project seems to have become nearly a way of life. I was thinking that this piece is a bit long, at 17 minutes, but yet there seems to be more and more to say. Then I was thinking about sending a postcard myself. Thinking about it leads to that, somehow. WHY?

Comment for "Right Between the Ears #001" (deleted)

User image

Review of Right Between the Ears #001 (deleted)

The audience sounds like they're having a blast at this anniversary edition of this comedy offering and Liane Hanson, in a guest appearance on this live comedy show, really sounds like she is, too. The show is professionally and confidently done, and I like the performances, including the voice imitations of presidents past and present. Some of the skits made me laugh outloud - such as Gregorian chant versions of sitcom theme songs - some were pretty bold and edgy (a debate about sex with several children's TV characters) and a couple were a bit more folksy-gosh than is my taste.

Comment for "10 Faure's Fiascoes"

User image

Review of Faure's Fiascoes

Looking around for something to listen to for my own pleasure, to take a break Excellent choice, Madame. (And what wine should I have with this?) I knew little about Faure, had a taste for knowing more - this satisfied that desire. I really enjoyed the music and the info delivered with it in the host's capable but youthful voice.

Comment for "Memento Pilot"

User image

Review of Memento Pilot

An idea for radio with potential ? people?s relationship to things. Everything in the production seems done right ? nice mixing, editing of attractive, articulate voices well recorded ? the story carefully told, described in the moment - but quite oddly ? these moments ? a guy stealing a gravestone and a guy stealing a Buddha ? are a bit too laidback and cool to draw me in. The young guy is questioned about his interaction with a gravestone he?s had for ten years. Has he related to it? ?No ? not really ? caretaking of the stone.? He left Banff ? because there was really ?nothing to do but watch television.? But has his life since become more interesting? The next guy lost a thumb but he's pretty matter of fact, too. Although he?s an attractive interview, funny and light about the hospital scene. Was the theft of the Buddha important? No, it was fuelled by booze. He admits it changed him - he realized he shouldn?t steal and he'd like his thumb back. But the host presses on, trying to find significance that doesn?t really seem to be there. Both stories last beyond their pay off. Is it because the people aren't New York-ish and neurotic enough for me? I'd like to hear what someone else thinks!

Comment for "With a Bullet (clean and short)"

User image

Review of Love & Radio: With a Bullet (clean and short)

Let?s admit up front that this reviewer is the perfect target ? the program has all the attributes that I fall for big time: it's modern-sounding, edgy and sonic with dead-on clean and subtle recording and mix ? the content is literary, with a couple of compelling short stories, impeccably read. At first I wondered, now wait, who are they? There was a young woman and man going to firing range to shoot a gun and I thought WHY? I wondered if the girl was the same one who was telling a story and exhibiting a hell of a healthy attitude about guns and I thought so why go and do that?! But this time, pay no attention to that listener behind the ether curtain, she?s still with you ? the outcue, tallying up who wrote and read and did what was all the explanation I needed. I got it. This program has a high WHAZZAT? Factor ? and pays it off.

Comment for "Life on the Outside"

User image

Review of Life on the Outside

Pristine, professional production - traditional "trac-and ac" NPR style news reporting at its best. The reporter captures lovely details, from the succinct expression of the homeless man's appreciation of life on the upside - "beautiful. Clean clothes, a place to sleep. Lately I've just been so glad to be alive," to the downside, "I don't know. I don't...know. Around" when asked where he's been. I am as fascinated by the careworkers on the job as I am by the subjects themselves - and being sinside their experience takes us - well (I'll speak for myself) - ME to a basic place where I bottom line place I feel profoundly called to over and over.

Comment for "Hanukkah: A Great Miracle Happened There"

User image

Review of Hanukkah: A Great Miracle Happened There

Everything You Always Wanted to Know About..Hanukkah. I'm one of those that doesn't know much, except the old saw about it being a minor holiday to compete with Christmas, which turns out to be somewhat true. Larry's guide and guest, Rabbi Ismar Schorsch, chancellor and history chair of the Jewish seminary in New York, is knowledgeable and articulate - and stick around for the moving personal Hanukkah story he modestly slips in. I'm not a Jew (except I'm a New Yorker which gives me a certain claim!)- but with the loud, simplified, all pervasive Christian clamor I'm hearing on all levels and from all corners coming from my native country I found this program a welcome, soothing and important listen.

Comment for "Intersect Perinatal Hospice"

User image

Review of Intersect Perinatal Hospice

A local program containing interesting and valuable information about prenatal hospice care. The producer has gotten really good interviews with parents, nurses and doctors ? these people are impressive. The subject is divided into four segments (which are also available on PRX in segment form). In the first, the section is really carried by an articulate parent ? in the last, the subject of language used in diagnosis and care was very interesting. I don?t understand the concept of the program: ?the interface of life with the human experience.? What is the difference between those two things exactly? Other comments: the producer needs to work on achieving a more natural phrasing and rhythm with his reading. The audio quality also needs to be improved. Recordings are noisy and a bit distorted, while the music is a little too saturated. And I KNOW how hard resolving that is now that we can all work alone!

Comment for "Finding My Ma"

User image

Review of Finding My Ma

A very young woman talks frankly to her mother, who has had some very troubled relationships - I was interested in their stories - I found the daughter amazngly level-headed and the mother engaging - I wanted to know more about them - like many youth-produced pieces, it begs for context. What did she know before? What parts were a surprise? Who are they? Where do they live? What are their ages? For me, the questions go on and on - and in that way the piece becomes incomplete - a longer program where several daughters do this kind of interview might be one idea.

Comment for "The Wire Episode 1: Hallo, Hallo"

User image

Review of The Wire Episode 1: Hallo, Hallo

Sonically beautiful - I tuned in out of interest in the subject - the origins of art and electricity - and stayed happy all the way through with the attention to compositional detail - the program would fit right in with any station combining even a bit of fresh, modern music with spoken ideas. I'm there for episode 2.

Comment for "The Last Yugoslavs"

User image

Review of The Last Yugoslavs

Straight from the heart, nicely done - During the first half of it I'm thinking, real sound would have been so much better than the music used - or silence - but then he does employ silence -and the use of the music is finally paid off as the piece comes to a well-played climax - and the music does give it an overall upbeat energy. My favorite part is the last line - which made me laugh outloud - Jonathan's boyhood Brooklyn humor, coming home.

Comment for "Christmas in the Trenches"

User image

Review of Christmas in the Trenches

The (positive) response to this piece on PRX got my attention - I'm the 7th reviewer - this story about WWI soldiers calling time out in the trenches is a lovely, telling story - but certainly not "little-known" over here - there's even a holiday season film out about it this year. Are we in the US really that unaware of what war is? I will say that I think it's a nice, thoughtful piece for the holidays - and I love the song featured - but I agree with other reviewers that it's too bad the interview is over the phone - but the information is useful.

Comment for "Carols on the Carillon"

User image

Review of Carols on the Carillon

Holiday bell sounds, beautifully recorded - with a nice musical explanation - nice palatte-cleanser for classical or news station for sounds of the season!