Comments by Transom Editors

Comment for "If Kids Must Work"

User image

Review of If Kids Must Work

A revealing picture of what life is like for the 2/3 of the world's kids living and growing up very quickly in developing countries. This is a free flowing piece, a collage of voices, from Africa and Central America. It consists of interviews with all the parties involved, from the kids themselves, to the parents to the NGOs who aim to help them. The kids interviews are often translated/read in english by Western kids which is a effective juxtaposition. The parents featured often expressed pride that their kids can contribute to the families wellbeing; the NGO's offer a pragmatic view of their work in developing countries, which recognises the needs of the families involved whilst trying to encourage/enable school attendance etc to improve.

Could make a powerful contribution to a program focusing on western kids lives, or any program dealing with issues facing the developing world HW.

Comment for "Matching Outfits Not Included"

User image

Review of Matching Outfits Not Included

This is an engaging study of character, family, relationship, trust, acceptance, and grace in a community…of two.
Would be good to air on Valentine’s Day, as part of a compilation on any of the above-mentioned topics, or as a break from the big news of the day. sl

Comment for "That Democracy Show"

User image

Review of That Democracy Show

It begins with this girl quoting her economics teacher: I grew up in the 60's and I understand how you feel, but there isn't going to be a revolution... - whoa...! all of a sudden "Question authority " is a theme, again.
I haven't heard anything like this on radio for a long time except for the occasional focused youth radio program.
Its real, coherent, and FRANK FRANK FRANK. There are a lot of kids pissed off about the way things are moving and that's pretty inspiring.The issues are so now and I hope that kids are scanning the radio Sunday night.
It has the straight up in-your-face feel of all the shows my daughter likes to watch but the CONTENT ! I'm actually listening with interest to the content. and not just because I'm eavesdropping on what my kid is into which is about how I feel listening to what she's watching. and also, it's funny, ready to laugh - Mo Rocca is the right host..
The voices are so coherent, and they come from a pretty vast selection - not just kids from the debate team. This could air again, targeting a younger audience and I can't wait to hear what the call-ins will be. NO lie.
VM

Comment for "Third Coast'n"

User image

Review of Third Coast'n

This is a 30-second hit of road music and I like it. It suggests an entire category for the PRX which would be little interstitial bites -- sounds, music, voices -- which a station could use like carts for transition, change of pace, sorbet. Most public stations aren't programmed this way, but it would be interesting for some creative curators to experiment in blocks of a few hours of an evening. A style could emerge. -JA

Comment for "Democracy, American-Style: "Roberts' Rules of Democracy""

User image

Review of Democracy, American-Style: "Roberts' Rules of Democracy"

The sound quality is a little rough, but it's just great hearing this guy's insightful two cents on those valuable rules. sl

Comment for "RIT Video Game Masters"

User image

Review of RIT Video Game Masters

Even if you're not a video game aficionado (confessing here, NOT) this piece offers interesting look at related aspects of this area of technology. sl

Comment for "Whose Vote Counts?"

User image

Review of Whose Vote Counts?

Excellent report on a variety of critical voting issues: the pros and cons of electronic voting machines; the disparity of voting conditions in poorer communities; the struggle of those with felony convictions to recover their vote. The reporting is thorough and well-rounded, the narrative flows, the tape compelling. In the public interest, and a reminder to apathetic or discouraged voters, that for the disenfranchised, the vote is a precious, hard-won privilege. sl

Comment for "Chess Gals"

User image

Review of Chess Gals

The piece wanders a bit, but there’s good tape with real chess players and interesting information on chess-playing women and how they feel about their presence in that world. sl

Comment for "The Fight Is For Democracy" (deleted)

User image

Review of The Fight Is For Democracy (deleted)

Panel discussions do not make for the most sound-rich radio, but that aside, this conversation with reporters who’ve spent time in the Balkans and Iraq is well worth hearing for its thoughtful content. Where our soldiers and tax dollars go, our attention likewise should remain. This program is food for thought. sl

Comment for "White House Tapes: The President Calling"

User image

Review of White House Tapes: The President Calling

Take the ability to eavesdrop on three potent presidents, stir in a fast-moving, context-providing narrative, spice with insightful commentary from a shelf full of thoughtful historians, sprinkle with smidges of fine music, and sit back for a fascinating, engaging, amusing, and instructive hour of great radio. sl

Comment for "Primary Participation"

User image

Review of Primary Participation

Interesting report, well recorded and well-chosen tape makes you feel like you’re sitting right there, jawing with the locals. A good warm-up piece for election season. sl

Comment for "My Family Tis of Thee"

User image

Review of My Family Tis of Thee

Macsai wields her wand of humour with great dexterity making her points irrefutably dead on. Also she's got that way of connecting the oddest things that infuse you with a fresh way of looking. This is a good essay for Democracy theme but also other times of political introspection...4th of July???

Comment for "Justice Talking: Exporting Democracy"

User image

Review of Justice Talking: Exporting Democracy

A brief but useful warm-up report preps us for the debate that follows. Two impassioned, intelligent, opinionated gents have at this meaty topic, spurred on by thoughtful questions and Adler's skilled hosting and pointed questions. This is what I'd call public service programming at its lively best. sl

Comment for "Copper River Journey"

User image

Review of Copper River Journey

The telling of this river trip skillfully winds through information on the environment, development threats, and the poignant knowledge that this is near where the Exxon Valdez ran aground. We’re given the personalities of the rafting group and of the river itself, brought close-in to the richness of the experience. The producer confesses his fear of what he aptly calls eco-mysticism, but even if you feel the piece veers toward those shores, the joy and wonder of the rafters grabs you. And I ask, who can resist the sound of rushing water? sl

Comment for "Democracy In The Age Of Dubya" (deleted)

User image

Review of Democracy In The Age Of Dubya (deleted)

Predisposed to finding Al Franken right-on hilarious, this reviewer is utterly biased. Funny, pointed, angry, astute words. Let him rip, he rips. Great stuff. Confession: wrote this review in the first three minutes, but only in order to sit back and happily listen. sl

Comment for "Democracy, American-Style: "Mandela...Bush""

User image

Review of Democracy, American-Style: "Mandela...Bush"

This short monologue is worth airing for the ending. It is very affecting. In a few sentences, this South African women communicates the importance of voting in a truly affecting radio moment.

If you air this, and assuming it's okay with the producers, I'd recommend ending on her words, and following with music or some other breather before she identifies herself. The change in tone is awfully abrupt as it is. Alternatively, your local host could do the back announce. -J.A.

Comment for "Jehovah's Witness"

User image

Review of Jehovah's Witness

Moving, quiet piece. The narrator brings us inside with her sadness and feelings of loss. One hopes her mother can hear her heart. Good for any aged people to hear honest reflection by a young writer. sl

Comment for "Damascus Peace Meditation"

User image

Review of Damascus Peace Meditation

So brief, but so full. The sounds do something lovely to your body and mind. Like when you are deep in the day-to-day and suddenly look out the window just in time to catch an amazing sunset. Stop, hold the image. This has that quality. sl

Comment for "SF school split"

User image

Review of SF school split

Good, clear reporting accompanied by lively soundbed and an excellent range of community voices. Immigrant communities around the country have these very problems, so this piece would be valuable listening for much of the nation. Education has lost coverage since our latest war, but it's still a pressing concern for voters, so it will be forever timely. sl

Comment for "Profile of an Accidental Shooting"

User image

Review of Profile of an Accidental Shooting

This is a strong piece in every way. The voicing and writing are clear, the interviews intimate, and the subject compelling. Even though the central event occurred a few years ago, the subject remains important and the text here on PRX gives a current context for any station that might want to pick it up. If you were doing a series on gun control or safety, this piece would be a strong addition. - J.A.

Comment for "Fair Pay for a Day's Work"

User image

Review of Fair Pay for a Day's Work

National media often give short shrift to labor issues, so this is a welcome piece of work. Good range of voices, context, information, and detail. We get a real feeling for the issues at hand and for why the union-immigrant partnership is so crucial to the labor movement. sl

Comment for "What it Takes to be a Good Citizen"

User image

Review of What it Takes to be a Good Citizen

Interesting take on what it means to be a good citizen. The producer profiles two expressive women with very different priorities. A gentle visit with people like us – lots of demands on our time, genuine concern about government, but different ways of investing in society. sl

Comment for "Life Stories - Jobs: Teaching ("Educating Esme')"

User image

Review of Life Stories - Jobs: Teaching ("Educating Esme')

Beautifully produced journey through a new teacher’s first year in an urban school. Esme’s frank thoughts and vivid descriptions are well served by her personable delivery, whether imitating students, other adults, or herself. She’s a great guide to her own experience – good company, a wise and generous observer, an engaging speaker. The music accents are superb. sl

Comment for "interview with Bend it like Beckham filmmaker"

User image

Review of interview with Bend it like Beckham filmmaker

Entertaining, lively conversation with the director and screenwriter o f this popular film, along with audio clips. They talk about the origin, meaning, and process, as well as audience response. I haven’t seen this movie, but now I must. sl

Comment for "Be Connected Documentary on Emerging Energy Technologies"

User image

Review of Be Connected Documentary on Emerging Energy Technologies

Well-paced tour hither and yon through new and alternative energy technologies. Explanations are simple and clear enough for even an utterly non-science oriented listener, such as myself, to tag along without brain strain. Lots to learn here. sl

Comment for "Who Is Harvey Pekar?" (deleted)

User image

Review of Who Is Harvey Pekar? (deleted)

Oh Harvey, we love your whimsical, unique, observant self. Harvey makes us look at the world through his eyes, and it’s like when you walk out of a great movie and suddenly the world looks different…Go listen, and let your eyes open wide. Terrific production. sl

Comment for "Wu Man - Pipa player"

User image

Review of Wu Man - Pipa player

Lovely portrait-in-brief of this musician, in her own words, scored with gorgeous examples of pipa music. Good refresh-the-senses piece. sl

Comment for "Cyber Democracy and Civic Discourse"

User image

Review of Cyber Democracy and Civic Discourse

The potential power of on-line political discussion is real, but as this piece tells it, unbalanced, and in its infancy. Food for thought. sl

Comment for "Sisters"

User image

Review of Sisters

A lovely, reflective visit with a series of sisters of different generations underscored with lovely piano music. A good piece to drop in any old where you have a few minutes to fill. Refreshing. sl

Comment for "On Deaf Ears"

User image

Review of On Deaf Ears

We’ve got polls up the wazoo. This brief, well-paced piece touches on some of the concerns people and politicians in Utah have on the way to casting their votes. The same concerns exist nationwide. sl