Comments by Kerry Seed

Comment for "Ask the Librarian: Who's got better eyesight -- the jumping spider or the hawk?"

User image

Review of Ask the Librarian: Who's got better eyesight -- the jumping spider or the hawk?

This series about curiosity, research, and libraries asserts the relevance of libraries and librarians in our Internet age. Listeners hear the rich voice of Jackson Braider narrate this quest for information about eyesight in the wild. It's a quiet, simply produced piece packed with facts. Younger listeners will most likely pick up a few research tips along the way.

Comment for "Youth Portraits"

User image

Review of Youth Portraits

Every year thousands of young people are incarcerated in the United States' juvenile justice system. Most listeners will never have the opportunity to interact with a young person in who has served time. Fortunately for all of us, Sound Portraits producer, Stacey Abramson, has helped five young adults recently released from New York's Rikers Island to tell us their own stories.

These pieces are self-reflective, focusing on how the story tellers got into trouble and how they now make sense of their lives. Violent and deeply troubling, these stories are evidence of the radio's empathetic power to briefly merge the disparate lives of listener and storyteller. The stories have strong ties to New York but would fit well with any programming about juvenile justice.

Actor Rosie Perez provides brief context at the beginning and ending of each piece. Features are available as individual downloads. Strong language and graphic violence makes this series most appropriate for after hours broadcast.

Comment for "TOE/Celebritism"

User image

Review of TOE/Celebritism

Host Benjamen Walker tackles an interesting subject here: our obsession with celebrity. But, the production style of the show and the editing of the interviews combined to lull this listener into a daze.

There is not enough sonic variety in this half-hour to keep the ear involved. The show consists almost entirely of phone interviews mixed with instrumental music and Walker's sparse yet affected narration, giving the Theory of Everything the sound of one overlong This American Life introduction.

While the selection of guests is a good mix, and Walker poses the right questions, the rambling segments could benefit from aggressive editing. For instance the show begins with six minutes and forty seconds of unidentified phone tape before we hear the host identify the show.

References to Paris Hilton's sexual proclivity, menage-a-trois, sticking pills up your ass, and a couple of bleeped f-bombs make this more suitable for after hours broadcasting.

Comment for "Hip-hop in hunting boots"

User image

Review of Hip-hop in hunting boots

Music writer Chris Godsey introduces listeners Crew Jones, a rap group that rhymes about life in rural Minnesota. This is music journalism with some teeth; it's rare to hear this serious of a critque of underground hip-hop on public radio. The production style is conservative - listeners maintain a clinical distance from the live Crew Jones show, but this sound suits the tone of the piece which treats the Crew Jones music with an uncommon journalistic respect.

Comment for "undocumented"

User image

Review of undocumented

All the pieces are in place for this to be a standout feature about the daily realities of undocumented workers. The characters are strong. The story is important. The imagery is strong. But, the pacing is far too slow, and the voices of the Spanish to English translators are more engaged than the narrator's reading.

Comment for "Rise and Swell"

User image

Review of Rise and Swell

Danielle Simpson's young voice is incisive, rich in tone, and unique on the airwaves of public radio. Simpson's passionate discourse will grab your ears by force. Mourning the cruelty of life, economic injustice, and violence in our communities, Simpson has polished the angry words of this poem into a stark vein of despair. Her voice brings the truth of raw emotion to the airwaves. Her powerful oratory elevates this piece to a must listen.

Comment for "Roma and Son"

User image

Review of Roma and Son

Producer Hillary Frank guides listeners through a book published by Thomas Roma, an adult father photographer, and Giancarlo Roma, his young writer of a son. Simple music illustrates this examination of the fleeting relationship between fathers and sons. The editing style straddles the characteristics of a narrated feature and large chunks of straight interview to create an intimate window on creativity within families. A short and simple piece that took me to a contemplative corner of my mind. PDs beware that Studio 360's Kurt Anderson reads an intro.

Comment for "Just Off The Radar: 10-17-04"

User image

Review of Just Off The Radar: 10-17-04

Fans of World Cafe, Morning Becomes Eclectic, and American Roots will feel right at home with this eclectic hour of music straight from WUGA in Athens, Georgia. The mix jumps from the raw sounds of The Black Keys into an early Jamaican record, and features such disparate sounds as John Cale, Tom Waits, The Bees, and songs from the Mento Madness. Producer JoE Silva interjects polished commentary about the music, the artists, and upcoming Athens area performances. His phone interview with BBC DJ Gilles Peterson has an insiders' vibe that may resonate with knowledgable listeners, but those not familiar with Peterson could use either more context or a more aggressively edited interview. Silva could sound a little more engaged in what he's doing, but his sound is natural and therefore refreshing. A live e-mail competition and repeated announcements of upcoming Athens area events make this a tough piece to drop into programming.

 

Comment for "RN Documentary: Footnotes from the Fields"

User image

Review of RN Documentary: Footnotes from the Fields

"Footnotes from the Fields" provides listeners with a fresh context to consider the painful remnants of World War I. Radio Netherlands Producer, Marijke van der Meer takes listeners on a voyage to WWI's western front. Van der Meer follows a group of Dutch and American students who tour the battlefield with their professor. Listeners will hear students' reactions to their surroundings mixed with the explanatory sounds of the professor's tour and of museum guides. Van der Meer's slow narration provides greater historical context and additional layers of information.

Comment for "Santa Laws"

User image

Review of Santa Laws

This commentary is a sweet and funny take on Christmas traditions that would be a good add for any holiday programming. The piece begins and ends with the light jazzy tones of Santa Claus is Coming to Town. In between the musical bookends, Sean O'Connor delivers a polished commentary on the wardrobes of Santas everywhere. O'Connor's voicing is more professional sounding than the material merits. The writing is tongue in cheek but the delivery is not.

Comment for "The Walls"

User image

Review of The Walls

Umm... I'm not sure where you'll find a spot for a piece that begins with the sound of urinating, and maybe it's a little too long - BUT - at the two minute mark, this collage of voices reading bathroom walls takes a surprising and human turn as listeners hear women using the bathroom walls as a relationship advice column. Great tape of anonymous voices using an anonymous location to be real with each other.

Comment for "That's My Song: Under Pressure"

User image

Review of That's My Song: Under Pressure

NPR's popular series, "What Are You Listening To?" can't hold a candle to the real world sensibility and depth of this piece about San Francisco high-schooler Max Hsing's favorite song. The classic Queen vs Bowie cut, Under Pressure, reminds Max not only of how the world initially turned its back to the AIDS epidemic. Nobody had the facts about AIDS until it had already snuffed out the bright lights of Queen singer, Freddie Mercury and Hsing's own uncle. A simple mix of Under Pressure and Hsing's contemplation, asks lasting questions about what might have been had we acknowledged AIDS sooner. Whether your program is about music, AIDS, or young people, you would do well to bring this piece to your listeners.

Comment for "Taking the SAT"

User image

Review of Taking the SAT

Every college bound high schooler takes the big, bad SAT. Chris Waddy has a lot of accomplishments under his belt - but a disappointing SAT score. In this piece Chris Waddy weaves together his commentary with a variety of sounds, expert interviews, and live tape from his law firm internship to examine how scoring 850 on the SAT will affect his life. Other than a slightly overlong lesson in statistics, this piece is a tightly written and compelling look at an issue that is very important to a wide segement of listeners.

Comment for "Boredom"

User image

Review of Boredom

Youth producer, Callie Dean masterfully tells the story of a summer run-in with the police. Crammed with visual details, this irreverent story unfolds moment by moment, augmented by just the right amount of sound rich re-enactment. Dean's cheeky timing unerringly pulls listeners through her compelling account of what can happen to a young person when you mix the doldrums of summer with a police force interested in criminalizing young people.

Comment for "Cell Phone Sing A Long!"

User image

Review of Cell Phone Sing A Long!

Humorist Merle Kessler, AKA Ian Shoales speedily comments on technology mitigating our enjoyment of life. Instead of lighters, rock fans now hold aloft picture phones. The sassy commentary is funny and full of excellent imagery. However, the pace of Kesslers reading may blow right by many listeners.

Comment for "Dream of Democracy"

User image

Review of Dream of Democracy [BG]

A record number of young people registered to vote in 2004, and we don't yet know what their impact will be on the election. If you're looking for a sound rich way to examine the voices of this new generation of voters, look no further. Barrett Golding & Jonathan Menjivar of Hearing Voices produced "Dream of Democracy", a twenty-nine minute special for WBEZ's Chicago Matters "Our Next Generation". The special is posted both as a full program and as individual segments ranging between 90 seconds and seven minutes in length.

Listeners hear Chicago area college students' view of the state of democracy in the United States. Stark, original music by Jeff Arntsen of Racket Ship scores this contemplative and existential look at young people's vision of the health of our society. Topics include: What's Democracy?, Politics of Youth, Youth Vote, What Politicians Do,The Pink Bloque (see below), Politics of Rap, and the American Dream.

The program takes an unexpected and exciting turn during a five minute segment about The Pink Bloque, a performance protest group that brings the "femme back to feminism". Dynamic voices of young women talk about the role of protest and dissent in the marketplace of ideas while sounds of a Pink Bloque event (which apparently includes dancing to OutKast).

Soon there after, Golding and Menjivar bring a host of seldom heard African American voices to the piece, investigating the role of hip hop in US democracy.

Comment for "Pop Vultures #19: Usher & Breakup Songs" (deleted)

User image

Review of Pop Vultures #19: Usher & Breakup Songs (deleted)

She breaks up with me. I call my friend and dish the pain. I turn on the radio, and the songs are all about my life. In a nutshell, you have the concept of this episode of Pop Vultures. Pop Vultures #19 takes on pop superstar Usher and the Breakup Song genre. Serious music programming this ain't, but if you're looking to spice up your programming with a witty gossip send-up of our pop lives, turn with conviction to Pop Vultures #19. The voice of this show is a relaxed version of the typical public radio sound. Hosts conversationally talk about the meaning of the sweaty, lovestruck music of Usher over a bed of Usher's greatest. Mid-program the focus broadens to include a similar treatment of "breakup" music, spanning such artists as Willie Nelson, Common, and the Magnetic Fields.

Comment for "Crayola"

User image

Review of Crayola

A laid back speaker gives the history of Crayolas while young crayon users chime in favorite colors and reviews of each others' art. Allington's impeccable timing and creative mix will spice up any broadcast about creativity, arts education, or design.

Comment for "Davy Rothbart, Found Magazine"

User image

Review of Davy Rothbart, Found Magazine

Fresh, funny, spontaneous. All this and a flawless mix. Any community that will soon host Davy Rothbart and a Found Event will love to hear this on the airwaves. This piece is alive!

Comment for "The Stories of September Eleventh Families for Peaceful Tomorrows"

User image

Review of The Stories of September Eleventh Families for Peaceful Tomorrows

I think it is especially interesting to hear now, two years later, because it really took me back to that time, that feeling of awe and sorrow in the days immediately after the event. I also lost my father this year. So, I really related to the man from Ithaca's flashback stories as well as everyone's grief.

I'm really impressed with how you were able to piece together such a long program with no narration whatsoever. The spare use of music served you well.

I especially loved the first half. The second half hour was also well done, and very, very important. I've been thinking about why it didn't hold my attention as well as the first, and I think it is because the second leans more towards exposition and less towards anecdotal storytelling. In my opinion, if the piece was shorter, the lessons learned in the aftermath would stand out more prominently in the mix.