Comments by Deborah Astley

Comment for "1000 Postcards"

User image

Review of 1000 Postcards

Rene has quite a dad. 1,000 postcards are truly a monument of a father's love for his daughter. This piece is sound rich and it showcases a healthy, loving relationship between parent and child. While this piece would be perfect for Father's Day, it would also be good for that time in August and September when children are leaving home for college. Beautiful piece.

Comment for "Gramma Morgan"

User image

Review of Gramma Morgan

I enjoyed this piece very much. Julie Moody tells a story well. Always an artist, 87 year old Gramma Morgan now paints in the styles of pointillism and stiple pointillism because she is over 75 percent visually impaired. She also paints in brilliant colors. Although Gramma Morgan's floral paintings are described in the piece, I found myself wanting to actually see them, but I don't know when I'll be able to visit the Ruta Maya Coffee House. This piece could move from being regional to national if there was a website mentioned in the piece that listeners could visit to view some of Gramma Morgan's work. This piece would work well with other pieces on women, art, aging, family, retirement, and visual impairment.

Comment for "Norm Tabler #1"

User image

Review of Norm Tabler #1

I'm listening to Norm's satirical fundraising vignettes while working on a new display board for the NPR programs we air here at KCCU. Consequently, I'm surrounded by all the faces that Norm is talking about in his hiliarious pieces and I'm laughing hysterically. Staff members are asking me what I'm listening to. The piece about Nina Totenberg's wardrobe malfunction is especially funny.

Comment for "RN Documentary: Turning the Pages"

User image

Review of RN Documentary: Turning the Pages

This is a remarkable personal history told through the perspective of Robert Brouwer who, as a young man, was a page turner for famous musicians. He also collected their autographs. This guy knew Rachmaninoff! The listener travels to Holland and hears about pre WWII Amsterdam all from the perspective of the page turner. History might be read about in books but each of us are living parts of history and this piece brings out that fact. "Turning the Pages" is well balanced with descriptive narrative and music. The scenes are nicely developed in the listener's mind's eye. "Turning the Pages" needs a quiet contemplative time in the programming schedule - one that is already set aside for classical music or maybe part of a Sunday morning or afternoon weekend magazine show - because the beauty of the piece could be swallowed up if it were surrounded by unrelated programming. Beautiful well done piece which draws in the listener with the first touch of the piano keys.

Comment for "Epitaph"

User image

Review of Epitaph

I like this series. I'm a lover of words, as I believe the majority of public radio listeners are. Drawing from a wide variety of sources, the producer Chrysti Smith has developed a piece that catches the ear very well - it's smooth, entertaining, and informative. I especially liked the epitaph, "I told you I was sick." This piece would work well around Keillor's "Writer's Almanac" or anyplace in the programming schedule where two minutes of intelligence are needed. Good job.

Comment for "Rule of Thumb"

User image

Review of Rule of Thumb

I like this series. I'm a lover of words, as I believe the majority of public radio listeners are, so this piece is right up my alley. (Where did 'right up my alley' come from?) Drawing on a wide variety of sources, the producer Chrysti Smith has developed a piece that catches the ear very well -it's smooth, entertaining, and informative. This piece would work well around Keillor's "Writer's Almanac" or anyplace in the programming schedule where two minutes of intelligence are needed. Good job.

Comment for "Cowboy Campaign"

User image

Review of Cowboy Campaign

"People that are doing what they enjoy are fun to be around all day," says Ken Welch, ranch manager of Silverbrook. I love this piece. The description of the working ranch; the interviews with the cowboys and cowgirls, a photographer, a college professor, and a museum curator; and the description of the tintype method of photography all weave together to create a many layered picture in the listener's mind. The listener even learns that lavender oil was used to preserve tintype photographs 150 years ago and that Kendrick uses his own home grown lavender on his tintype photographs. Kendrick's photographs will be in a traveling exhibit entitled "Revealing Character." Julie Moody has produced a rich authentic indepth piece.

Comment for "Dowser, Consultant to the Universe"

User image

Review of Dowser, Consultant to the Universe

Glen Johnson has found the reason he is on earth. How many of us can say that? Mr. Johnson approaches the art of dowsing for water scientifically and spiritually. His dowsing rod responds to a higher power if he asks questions which are properly worded. He calls this higher power God because God is a three letter word that is easy to spell, easy to say and easy for people to comprehend. This piece is a showcase for two arts: the art of dowsing and the art of interviewing. Owen Agnew digs deeply and gets a frank, honest piece. This piece would fit in well with environmental pieces, pieces about what people do after retirement, and also pieces about faith.

Comment for "A Family Yarn"

User image

Review of A Family Yarn

Tennis ball fuzz. Spaghetti strings of yarn. Puffs of wool flying out of the old machinery that look like angels, snow, and poodles. Mrs. Marchelletta is a poet of the old woolen mills of Maine and Rupa Marya catches that poetry so well. As a country, we heard about NAFTA coming and about NAFTA being here, but we rarely hear about after NAFTA. This heartwrenching, heartwarming piece is about after NAFTA on a personal basis from the viewpoint of the Marchelletta family. My only question in this otherwise perfect, soundrich piece is where does the wool come from that the Marchelletta mill uses? I ask this because we have a flock of Suffolk sheep on our acreage here in southwest Oklahoma and I just wondered where the wool came from that was used for the tennis balls.

Comment for "StoryCorps: Danny and Annie Perasa"

User image

Review of StoryCorps: Danny and Annie Perasa

StoryCorps is great. I feel like I'm on a party line telephone (does anyone remember party lines?) and overhearing conversations. Danny Perasa is a master at the similes. Saying "I love you" is like "hearing a beautiful song from a busted old radio" or "being married is like having a color television; you never want to go back to black and white." Annie Perasa must be some kind of woman. Sweet spot for anytime especially for next month - June - which is the traditional time for weddings. Listen to this piece, then listen to Catherine Giradeau's piece on PRX entitled "Vows." The two would work well together.

Comment for "StoryCorps Button - INTRO" (deleted)

User image

Review of StoryCorps Button - INTRO (deleted)

Intimate introspective guitar music sets the stage for the excellent series, StoryCorps. When your listeners hear this music, they will know something special is coming next.

Comment for "StoryCorps: Billy Collins"

User image

Review of StoryCorps: Billy Collins

Funny, funny piece. I felt like I was sitting in a restaurant and overhearing a conversation in the booth in back of me. Funny and intimate. Put anywhere in your program schedule that a bright spot is needed. Thanks for the laughs.

Comment for "Night Flying"

User image

Review of Night Flying

Looking for great radio for young people? Here it is. I'm hooked. Having worked in elementary and high school libraries and parented my own two children, I know it is difficult to get young people to read. Somewhere around 6th grade, interest in reading dies down as other more demanding urges take over. A compelling chapter of Night Flying is presented by an excellent reader. I chose to listen to this excerpt because I've always dreamed of flying . . . without an airplane. In this internet age of interactivity, it is good that there is a companion website for young readers to learn more about the featured book and author. Listen to this piece and find out why pigeons in the barn are like bad relatives and what age has been chosen as the age of reason. Good intro and outro. As Bill Harley says, "reading is another way to fly" and "watch out for low flying women." This is good stuff!!

Comment for "THINK GLOBAL: Bill McKibben commentary"

User image

Review of THINK GLOBAL: Bill McKibben commentary

My favorite pieces on public radio are those that take a just a few minutes yet give me something to think about for the whole day - something to discuss with friends and family. This commentary does just that. The piece is well written and presented well. McKibben touches on why people are excited about new things from distant lands, but still long for the familiarity of their own stomping grounds. In a time when keeping things local is becoming difficult and it seems as if the whole world is turning into a "Tower of Babel," this piece tells about local people making a difference in their communities.

Comment for "My Body"

User image

Review of My Body

This courageous piece is cleverly shaped around ascending sizes of bras which then descend in size after surgery. Great intro and outro music. Whether well endowed, flat chested or somewhere in between, women already know what a burden breasts can be and will be able to relate to this one particular woman's experience. This piece brings out all the anxiety a woman feels about her body. It also has a comprehensive list of slang terms which are used to refer to women's breasts. While listening to it, I was reminded of the scene in Woody Allen's "Sleeper" where the gigantic breast was bouncing across the countryside. Take a listen. This is an important piece that everyone needs to hear. Well done.

Comment for "TOE/Books"

User image

Review of TOE/Books

Books are the ultimate organic representation of thought. Words written down and printed in books have a power like no other form of communication This piece by Benjamen Walker drives that point home. From the physical beauty and attraction of books to the love of collecting books, the piece explores the relationship between books and their owners. Author, book-blogger and publisher Dennis Loy Johnson, while talking about the decline of book features in newspapers and other media, also talks about the joy of discovering everyday people who have a novel in progress or a collection of poems ready to be read. He calls it "an underground movement of art" Great piece for a weekend show when one is at home listening to public radio, surrounded by one's books.

Comment for "Over-Identified"

User image

Review of Over-Identified

Once again Ian Shoales a/k/a Merle Kessler has managed to put a lot of thought-provoking and relevant information into a short period of time. Listening to his pieces is kind of like playing a pinball machine. He quickly hits on something important - BING - and then moves on to something else important - BING. How does he do it? Since identity theft seems to be on the news constantly now, this piece would work well on any of the news magazines such as All Things Considered, Morning Edition or Day to Day.

Comment for "Growth" (deleted)

User image

Review of Growth (deleted)

A lot of depth in 90 seconds. Growth is used literally and as a metaphor for other things in life. Would work well around other pieces about going to college, retiring . . . any life changing experience. Very thoughtful piece.

Comment for "The Change In Farming"

User image

Review of The Change In Farming

Wow! I had expected a short documentary about the changes in farming and instead I heard a unique musical and literary piece. Goddard hears people's voices as musical notes on a scale. He heard musical notes in his 89 year old grandfather's spoken words and turned them into a melody about the change in farming. The underlying beauty of this piece is the relationship between Goddard and his grandfather. This is a creative way to document personal histories. Wonderfully done.

Comment for "My Dad's Records"

User image

Review of My Dad's Records

Hoffman refers to his late father's record collection as "wisdom between the grooves." Great piece for Father's Day. This piece is a multi-generational passing down of history in the form of music. We get to listen to the touching and entertaining conversation between Hoffman and his young son as they go through Hoffman's father's record collection. Lots of music. It's also interesting to listen to Hoffman's six year old son describe a record player. It's disconcerting, though, to hear about record players being relegated to the status of historical artifacts! Great piece. Enjoyed it very much. Your listeners will too.

Comment for "The humble Farmer May 10, 2005" (deleted)

User image

Review of The humble Farmer May 10, 2005 (deleted)

I was totally thrown by the title of this very regional piece, "The Humble Farmer." I had seen it listed a couple of days ago on PRX and I thought, "This sounds like a really interesting piece," and I couldn't wait until I could find the time to listen to it. The tones listed at the site said that the piece is humorous and informational. Under "topics," the words entertainment, humor and music are listed. I expected much more in the form of humor and information. I did hear wonderful music punctuated by one liners and letters from listeners. Since radio is a theater for the mind, I imagined an older guy wearing a sweater with one sleeve rolled up and one rolled down - because he couldn't make up his mind. He's just finished a bowl of oyster soup and he's settled down for the evening in an overstuffed chair. Next to him is his record player and a stack of records. I really liked the music - it's perfect for an evening of relaxation. I just wish the piece had more talking from the Humble Farmer. When marketing this, the music should really be emphasized because that's basically what this piece is all about - the music.

Comment for "Natural History of Everything"

User image

Review of Natural History of Everything

Hey! Some of those books listed in this piece are sitting on my bookshelves and I've been to Chilicothe, Missouri, home of sliced bread. That's why this a great piece. It has so much energy that your listeners will get caught up in it. How about a natural history of public radio? This piece is for book lovers everywhere and could be a lead in for a more serious piece on literature.

Comment for "Visitor Center Fever: Catch It!"

User image

Review of Visitor Center Fever: Catch It!

Tis the season for family vacations and this short humorous piece would work well around a longer piece about vacations. Everyone has stopped at a visitor center at least once in their lives and this piece reveals how a new spin is being put on an old idea. The movie "West World" with Yul Brynner came to mind while listening to this piece. Robots!

Comment for "Blues File: review Duwayne Burnside "Under Pressure""

User image

Review of Blues File: review Duwayne Burnside "Under Pressure"

The apple doesn't fall far from the tree. Anyone familiar with R. L. Burnside's hard hitting honest blues will appreciate this review of "Under Pressure," the newest recording by R.L. Burnside's son, Duwayne. Meister's piece is as energetic as the musician and music he's reviewing. Meister provides lots of information packed into a short period of time, backed up by generous excerpts of Burnside's music. I listened to this piece several times. It would work well on a weekend jazz/blues program.

Comment for "Vows"

User image

Review of Vows

Timely introspective piece. There are many thoughtful reflections from people of different cultures and religions and from same sex and different sex couples -- they talk about the importance of their vows and the listener gets to hear some of those vows. Ten minutes well spent. Girardeau's use of maps as a metaphor for marriage is beautiful. She writes well - best words, best order. Because June is the traditional month for weddings, this piece would work well now and next month. A saxophone underlies it all. Need I say more?

Comment for "Another Lousy Day"

User image

Review of Another Lousy Day

The title and premise grabbed me. Found diaries in a thrift shop! How much longer will it be possible to find diaries at thrift shops with the advent of the computer and internet blogs? Sherlock Holmes and pre-Bridget Jones's Diary combined. Production is great. I enjoyed listening to Kodeski's bemused voice and Slickman's sometimes sardonic renderings of the diary entries. History at its most personal. Dare I say it's a modern day version of Samuel Pepy's diaries. Soundtracks from movies and time period add to the piece. The late fifties and early sixties come back with a vengeance. Seventeen minutes of great radio. Thank you.

Comment for "Here There is No Moon (European version 31:54)"

User image

Review of Here There is No Moon (Long Version)

Having been raised by a mother who has been and is constantly beset by the pains of manic depression and the wish to no longer be a part of the living, this piece speaks volumes to me. I am sure there are so many children, parents, and spouses in the public radio listening audience that will benefit from hearing this piece. Many times loved ones cannot speak about their darkest feelings with each other. This piece will provide an opening for dialogue. These voices, from the ones feeling the pain to the ones who are helping those in pain, to excerpts from literature, reveal things to all of us that need to be said. This piece brought to mind Edna St. Vincent Millay's poem, "Spring," which ends with these final lines: "It is not enough that yearly down this hill, April comes like an idiot, babbling and strewing flowers." Riveting, wonderful piece. Sound rich. Well done. Listen. All of us have had at least one day in our lives where there's been no moon . . . and no sun.

Comment for "Neoconservatives as a cult..."

User image

Review of Neoconservatives as a cult...

This short piece about the neo-conservative movement stands out because it is done by youth. It is refreshing to hear a young voice talk about the current political situation. This piece would be good to air if only because it brings a freshness to what has already been said about this particular topic. Great music.

Comment for "A Short History of Music as a Weapon"

User image

Review of A Short History of Music as a Weapon

It is amazing what human beings do to one another. This short piece is chock full of information that shows that while music might have charms to soothe the savage breast, it can also be used to scare, humiliate and destroy human beings. A sound-rich piece, the listener will learn that, two centuries ago, the British banned the bagpipe and declared it a weapon of war. Now the bagpipe is used as a heartwrenching instrument during funeral marches. (Is any instrument more plaintive? Maybe the harmonica.)A variety of other musical artists,instruments, and sounds are featured as weapons of torture. It would be the sound of a dental drill that would finally break me. This piece would fit in whenever there was any news from Iraq. The piece could also stand alone. Five minutes well worth a listen, it would grab me wherever I was and whatever I was doing. I would turn to my friend and say, "Shhh . . . listen to this."

Comment for "Time-Lapse Radio: The Muralist" (deleted)

User image

Review of Time-Lapse Radio: The Muralist (deleted)

Murals on the outside of public buildings have become increasingly popular over the years. It takes a brave artist to work in public and listen to the comments, both good and bad, of passers-by. Lyle Kissack is just such an artist - a performance artist really. He scrambles up a scaffold to do a three story mural - christened "Unity Wall" - on a building on the corner of Guilford and 20th in Baltimore. The interviews with Kissack are inciteful. Listeners will learn how this particular artist blocks out his murals and about the preparation work that is involved before the actual mural is painted. We also learn that part of the enjoyment for Lyle is getting to know the people who are a part of the neighborhood in which he is working. The most engaging part of the piece is when the school children come for a day to help paint animals and rocks. Background street sounds are great. Listeners will feel like they are outside in early spring in Baltimore. The wrap-up interview with Linda, a resident of the neighborhood, is an excellent ending to this heartwarming piece. This piece would work well now as school is ending or in early summer.