Comments by Deborah Astley

Comment for "Roberto: We Don't Live in Huts"

User image

Review of Roberto: We Don't Live in Huts

KCCU Public Radio is located at Cameron University in Lawton, Oklahoma. We have many students majoring in communications who come from the Caribbean islands of the Bahamas, St. Kitts, St. Lucia and other islands. Roberto's comment that Americans thought he had lived in a hut when he was in the Bahamas rings true with comments I've heard from the Caribbean students here at Cameron. They received similar comments upon their arrival in Oklahoma. I must point out, though, that Roberto did learn that our streets are not paved with gold. The beauty of pieces like this is that it shows how important it is to hear stories from everyone and everywhere. Roberto provides a unique perspective and deserves to be shared.

Comment for "Mariachi Corner"

User image

Review of Mariachi Corner

I have a confession to make: I'm scared of mariachi bands, kind of like some people are scared of clowns. This piece, however, blew me away. It is very well written with wonderful, colorful descriptions of each place that is visited and interviews with members of mariachi bands. Lots of music with history thrown in. I felt like I was there . . . and I wasn't scared! Loved it. I notice that it originally aired on PRI's MarketPlace in 1999. It's been six years . . . it needs to be aired again.

Comment for "My Muslim Hairdresser"

User image

Review of My Muslim Hairdresser

A beauty shop and a place of worship have a lot in common - usually one comes out of both of these places feeling like a new person. Shana Sheehy introduces listeners to her Muslim hairdresser who tells about her conversion to the Muslim faith, difficulties encountered, and how she handled them. Listeners will hear the sounds of the beauty shop in the background: the snipping of the scissors, the running of the water. They will feel like they are sitting in the chair next to these two women, eavesdropping. I would like to hear it in a newsmagazine setting - morning or afternoon. Interesting take.

Comment for "Merrie Spaeth CPB Commentary"

User image

Review of Merrie Spaeth CPB Commentary

I was dubious when I read the description of Merrie Spaeth's piece. I found this to be a good piece that lays out Ms. Spaeth's opinions well. She comes from a different angle that is interesting to hear. That's the whole point of public radio, isn't it? Not to be cheerleaders for our own point of view, but to listen to every point of view and then decide for ourselves? Give this a listen and find a spot for it.

Comment for "For Whom the Bell Tolls"

User image

Review of For Whom the Bell Tolls

Braider's Zen-like piece is beautiful in its simplicity. It would fit in well during an afternoon news magazine when people are driving home from work. As I listened to the measured gongs of the bells and the "make each word count" style that Braider does so well, stress melted away. Listeners will definitely be served food for thought with this piece. It's an excellent thinking piece.

Comment for "Witness to an Execution"

User image

Review of Witness to an Execution

As a society, we constantly try to shield ourselves from reality. We like our violence in slick CSI fashion - 10 minute segments with commercials in between, easy on the eye actors, and definite endings. Listen to Witness to an Execution. This is what public radio is all about - it holds up a mirror to all segments of society and we see our reflections. It's about every day Americans just doing their jobs; their jobs just happen to be putting people to death. No matter on what side of the fence you stand regarding the death penalty, you must give this piece a listen. It is brave, it is haunting, it is powerful, it will move you to tears. Find a place for this piece in your programming schedule.

Comment for "End of a Red-Hunter's Crusade: The Censure of Joseph McCarthy"

User image

Review of End of a Red-Hunter's Crusade: The Censure of Joseph McCarthy

I'm from the generation that did the "duck and cover drills" in grade school. I watched my father plan escape routes from my hometown of Oklahoma City in case the Soviets finally dropped the "big one." The Soviets never dropped the big one, I spent much of my childhood afraid of something that never came to pass, and I see the same things happening again today. At that time, it was Joseph McCarthy's voice that provided the soundtrack for our lives - be afraid, be very afraid. Now it's the current administration - be afraid, be very afraid. Twenty-first century fear has evolved into color coded terrorist alerts and the misnamed Patriot Act. In addition to giving listeners a historical perspective, Brian Bull draws parallels between then and now. Soundclips from that time are included as are interviews with people today who, surprisingly, think McCarthy was a wonderful patriot. This piece is put together well, timely, and worth a listen.

Comment for "Commentary: Is it Labor Party Time?"

User image

Review of Commentary: Is it Labor Party Time?

Well thought out piece by Mr. Meister although I feel like it's a cry in the wilderness. If your station airs political programs, find a place for this one if you want to start a dialogue. There was a discussion today at KCCU about voting apathy and the feeling that one is voting against rather than for a person or a political platform. Even though the national election is over, the discussion still continues, and this piece about the revival of the Labor Party as a viable alternative is one worth listening to.

Comment for "How I Helped Found the United Nations"

User image

Review of How I Helped Found the United Nations

The May 23, 2005 issue of The New Yorker had an article about a temporary move in 2007 of the United Nations from Manhattan to Brooklyn while the UN is being renovated. With that in mind, this piece is about when the UN was still on the other side of the nation, in San Francisco. The listener will hear the memories of Mr. Meister as he talks about being a 12 year old Boy Scout aide at the founding conference of the UN. A worldwide event told from a personal perspective. Even though this piece was done in response to the anniversary of the Founding Conference, because the UN is often in the news, I think this piece would be appropriate in conjunction with other UN pieces.

Comment for "March of the Salamanders"

User image

Review of March of the Salamanders

Head to the streets for salamanders and frogs. This is an interesting piece about the mating mayhem that ensues each spring in Amherst; as was pointed out in the piece,though, the mayhem goes on all over the country. It's wonderful that Amherst built migration tunnels for these amphibians in love. Everywhere one looks, one can see the effects of manmade structures' encroachment on the age old rituals of wildlife. Lots of information packed into a short span of time. Even though spring is rapidly edging into summer, this piece would still be timely.

Comment for "The Balloon Hat Experience"

User image

Review of The Balloon Hat Experience

Add some whimsy to your listeners' day by airing this piece about an imaginative guy named Addi and his friend, Charlie, who travel the world making balloon hats and spreading smiles. The listener will hear the squeaks of balloons being twisted and the smiles in the voices of the balloon hat recipients. (The balloon hat website should definitely be mentioned so listeners can actually see the photographs or make it a web extra like on the NPR newsmagazine shows. Gurian does a great job of describing the balloon hats, but it's fun to actually see colorful examples.) Balloons - a non-threatening entry into diverse cultures - who knew? Great concept and a day brightener.

Comment for "Bringing The Work Into You"

User image

Review of Bringing The Work Into You

This is a wonderful piece about one person's way of dealing with loss and grief. The use of the sounds and the silences is as arresting as the topic itself. Today's hurry up society is much better at hellos than goodbyes. Not so very long ago, people used to wash and prepare their loved ones' bodies for burial; our society once had a much more intimate relationship with the deaths of loved ones. In a final tribute to his mother, Luce builds her casket as his last goodbye. Luce has taken a different path and it's one that public radio listeners will want to hear.

Comment for "Father's Day"

User image

Review of Father's Day

The human voice can evoke so many more emotions than an image. Does the ear have a direct line to the heart? It must because this piece is an emotional one. This is a well-done piece featuring a little boy and his father, narrated by the little boy all grown up. Perfect for Father's Day. Warning: it's a tear jerker.

Comment for "Cobb's Ice Harvest"

User image

Review of Cobb's Ice Harvest

Cool, cool piece. Air it during the long hot summer. Historical background is given and the listener will hear the chug-chug of the ancient ice cutter and the slick whoosh-whoosh of the long two handed saw. It's a "shhh, I'm listening," tilt your head toward the radio piece.

Comment for "PowerPoint at Gettysburg, rev."

User image

Review of PowerPoint at Gettysburg, rev.

Well done piece. Enjoyed the "OZ" comparisons very much. I recently wrote a paper entitled "To PowerPoint or Not to PowerPoint: That is the Question." The original designer of PowerPoint never intended for the program to have templates. The program was to contain blank slides for the creator's ideas. The templates were started when MicroSoft purchased the program. Studies conducted by MS revealed that people were having a hard time coming up with their own ideas and needed a prescribed jumping off point; hence the templates. I liked Braider's comment, "When you have a hammer like that [PowerPoint], everything else becomes a nail." I still contend it's not the program itself - it's the way people use it. Thought provoking piece and still timely as PowerPoint abuse continues.

Comment for "Family Vacation"

User image

Review of Family Vacation

Funny and well-done. "Forced intimacy" and "raised hackles" - Jesse expresses herself very well. The irony of this piece is that "experts" say that the intimacy of the car encourages discussion with one's teenager. So much for experts. Great piece to air especially during the summer vacation season or maybe during the Thanksgiving/Christmas season which is also a big family drive time.

Comment for "Vinyl"

User image

Review of Vinyl

I was fascinated and absorbed by this piece for the first two minutes. I got goosebumps from the record static - its "almost there" quality really made me sit forward and listen in anticipation. Fire crackled and hailstones plummeted to earth. Having said this, though, I'm not sure where it would fit into a programming schedule. And I kind of felt like my son had come to me and said, "Mom, listen to what I did with your Beatles records." Innovative use of vinyl.

Comment for "Personals"

User image

Review of Personals

If nothing else, this piece is worth a listen because of the Episcopalian and Sunny Delight. (That would be a story right there . . . what if the Episcopalian and Sunny Delight were to hook up?) The voice mail personals were interesting to listen to, but the piece needs more narration from Casey to bring it all together. Catchy intro music.

Comment for "The Perks of Studying to Heavy Metal"

User image

Review of The Perks of Studying to Heavy Metal

"Why are you listening to that #%! music?" How many generations have asked that question? As one who has been questioned about my own preference for heavy metal while walking, I can only say "each to his or her own." This is a smart piece by someone who knows her music and makes educated choices. This piece would fit in well during news magazine programming. Probably the best time would be mid-September, a couple of weeks after school starts. This piece would certainly start discussions between the generations. Good job.

Comment for "Regarding BS" (deleted)

User image

Review of Regarding BS (deleted)

This short, straight forward piece on the subject of BS would be appropriate any time, any day, any season of the year because BS is always with us. And, yes, there should be courses beginning in preschool on BS detection. I laughed out loud when McDonald related that the first time he realized he had been BS'd was by his mother - it involves the Jetsons and a rocket belt. Give this piece a listen.

Comment for "Lapsarian Hummingbirds"

User image

Review of Lapsarian Hummingbirds

Flying hogs of Plato? Good summertime piece even though reference is made to the groundhogs' hold on the media which temporarily yanked me back to February. I know the hummingbirds are twittering, hovering and divebombing around my feeders as I'm sure they are around other public radio listeners' homes. The metaphor between hummingsbirds and human beings is apt and showcased well by the poem. This would be a good piece to drop in before or after a piece by the Doyenne of Dirt perhaps? Easy to listen to summertime piece with an ending by Seals and Croft that made me smile. It fit in well with the overall tone of the piece. Entertaining.

Comment for "4th of July Fireworks"

User image

Review of 4th of July Fireworks

Humorous, satirical, well done. This piece is perfect for BEFORE the 4th of July. The fireworks stands are already popping up along the rural roadsides. The version with the music bed gave me a sense of urgency that wasn't there when I listened to the dry version. This piece will certainly liven up any line-up in which it is placed.

Comment for "To Bag or Not to Bag" (deleted)

User image

Review of To Bag or Not to Bag (deleted)

Great piece. This piece is very timely for summer, the Season of the Great Lawn Mower. Different voices and different opinions are all presented in an amusing manner. The listener will find himself or herself rooting for David as he searches for an authoritative recommendation that agrees with his viewpoint on the topic of whether or not he should bag his grass clippings. Perfect for Morning Edition or All Things Considered. Enjoyable.

Comment for "The Bottle King"

User image

Review of The Bottle King

Emily Sapienza enunciates her words well and what words they are. She is an excellent story teller. The listener meets Bram Hepburn, King of the Bottle Diggers. Bram is the kind of man who is so excited about his avocation that he even mentions "a guy's breath formed that" when speaking of an old bottle he's found. He feels a direct connection to the last person that held the bottle. Perhaps even more important than the bottle itself is the search . . . which could be applied to many things in life. This is a great piece that would fit in anywhere that one needed to fill a 7 minute slot. Good radio.

Comment for "Local News Sucks"

User image

Review of Local News Sucks

This piece is a diamond in the rough. Media savvy Ben Hyde lays it on the line about local news and what he finds wrong with it. Interwoven with his collage of newsclips are his comments. Everything he says is true, it just needs to be said more clearly and succintly. The piece brings out the powerful ability of the media to hone in on a trivial subject and give it more credence than it's due. The clip of the news station that had people strip an SUV in its studio is especially interesting. Is the news really news, or just entertainment? Good stuff. Just needs to be tightened up.

Comment for ""EchoTaps" (866 people play Taps)"

User image

Review of "EchoTaps" (866 people play Taps)

Echo Taps is a beautiful, uplifting concept. While listening to the piece, I imagined all the buglers stretching 41 miles from one town to the next, and the people waiting for the song to drift to them. A lovely thing. The piece begins with authoritative interviews that give background on the history of Taps and talks about bugles. The descendants of General Butterfield, the originator of Taps, are interviewed also. Who has listened to Taps and not gotten a lump in one's throat? The finale - 866 horns playing Taps all at once - is beautiful and listeners will stop whatever they are doing just to hear it.
Well done and perfect for Memorial Day or even Fourth of July.

Comment for "Cultivating the Humanure Revolution" (deleted)

User image

Review of Cultivating the Humanure Revolution (deleted)

One can hear the amusement in Curtis's voice as he talks about his mother and her great adventure with changing her style of personal waste management. The listener gets to hear Curtis's mother as she calmly explains how and why she has chosen to revolutionize her life in such a way and the laughing Kelsey as she explains her reluctance to use the system. I am old enough to remember trips outside to my great-grandfather's Kansas outhouse when I was very small and the memories are not especially pleasant, but maybe that was because there was no sawdust. One wonders how this method would work in the southern climes. I note that Curtis's mother lives in Maine. This piece would work well during the "Think Global" campaign or perhaps as a companion piece to one about the environment. Really! Not everyone living on this blue planet has a porcelain throne upon which to sit and maybe somewhere out there there is a piece about human waste disposal as handled in other countries.

Comment for "Dad's Paper"

User image

Review of Dad's Paper

This is a very moving piece that would be perfect for Father's Day or during a time when there is a focus on the ravages of Parkinson's Disease. The piece is built around the morning newspaper and its importance to Marsha's father who is suffering from Parkinson's Disease. Marsha talks about the repercussions of the decision her mother made to cancel the paper and how a neighbor helped out after that decision was made. Her dad still wanted to go through the motions. Sometimes life becomes as simple as that: going through the motions. Well done piece. Give it a listen.

Comment for "Prairie Burn Audio Postcard"

User image

Review of Prairie Burn Audio Postcard

One can almost feel the heat and smell the smoke as the listener is drawn into this piece. I originally heard it on Day to Day and enjoyed it very much. The people interviewed described their jobs well - the equipment and the clothing that are used are described so well that the listener can see them. I especially liked Catherine's comment that the landscape reminded her of a Dr. Seuss story. Great piece.

Comment for "The Iowa Way" (deleted)

User image

Review of The Iowa Way (deleted)

Coming from another "vowell" state, I was curious about this piece. It is fun to hear New Yorkers' attempts to describe Iowa, a beautiful state in which I once spent a week. This piece balances misconceptions about Iowa against the reality of Iowa. I like that the residents of the "city that never sleeps" were asked to comment about the state whose name might have come from an old American Indian term for "one who puts to sleep." This piece would work well in a travel magazine show or even a newsmagazine program if one was looking for something light. While primaries are still a long way off, this piece would also work well around that time.