Comments for My Lobotomy

Piece image

Produced by Piya Kochhar, Dave Isay

Other pieces by Sound Portraits

Summary: One man's quest to uncover the hidden story behind the lobotomy he received as a 12-year-old child.
 


Wow. Powerful.

I can see why this one caused a stir. It punched me in the gut. The somber, contemplative piano music fit well, too.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of My Lobotomy

It was an excellent piece of work--I never knew someone could come out of a lobotomy without being a vegetable...what a blessing he could get his answers and find peace for his soul!

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of My Lobotomy

This portrait of a man who got a lobotomy when he was 12 years old is disturbing and fascinating. Usually lobotomies are referred to in historical terms, "This is what happened, this is why they stopped performing them" and the story stops there. However, this piece looks at the lasting effects of this horrible practice to see what now, what has happened to the survivors? I love the contemporary view that this piece takes, as the man in the story reconstructs what happened to him and why. It's a terribly moving piece, culminating in a gorgeous song that encapsulates the mood expertly.

Caption: PRX default User image

Thank you

Thank you Howard, for sharing your story. And thanks to Sound Portraits for producing this beautiful, touching, disturbing piece.

User image

Review of My Lobotomy

My Lobotomy left me as numb as if I'd just had one. This piece is told with truthful honesty. The man in the story, Howard, must be a very brave person. The music running underneath the piece adds an element of experiencing a horror flick come to life and then moves toward a reflective mood. A very well rounded piece. Even Howard helps us laugh as he jokes about how affordable his lobotomy cost. Also the flow in and out of scenes is smooth and clear.

User image

Review of My Lobotomy

The most chilling radio story I have ever heard. Infact, the first time I heard it I felt physically ill. This is an incredibly brave and important story that should be required listening for all. I believe this already aired nationally on Morning Edition or All Things Considered but if you're a station that doesn't pick up those shows I think you should consider investing in this as a weekend special. Who knew how rampant lobotomy was as a practice? Not I.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of My Lobotomy

Very interesting story. I didn't know that much about the lobotomy movement other than it happened. The narrator seems well adjusted enough despite never knowing what was taken from him. I'd recommend this story for anyone with a free half hour who's interested in mental health. This piece serves as a careful reminder than while science has brought us many good things, if you don't use it responsibly it can be harmful as well. The idea of lobotomies being used to modify personality and behavior seems barbaric nowadays, but it's important to learn about our recent past. It reminded me of the eugenics movement that happened in America at the turn of the last century. Already, it seems, that memory has fallen out of the collective consciousness, but less than 100 years ago, thousands of people were sterilized against their will to protect the gene pool from further contamination from "imbeciles" and "undesirables". So, if for nothing else, I would also recommend this piece so that people do not forget what happened. Take this story as a warning that new and more radical treatments should always be used cautiously.

User image

Review of My Lobotomy

How can something so disturbing be so beautiful? This is an old story: a man?s search for self. But the context is thoroughly modern. He is ?disabled? by a lobotomy. But this procedure committed upon him at the age of twelve perversely provides a driving force to his quest, and in the process this shadow over his life became a vehicle for his reconciliation with self. One cannot help but feel joy for him, inspired by but also slightly jealous of his success ? and the clarity of this shadow over his life ? a clarity commonly (and perversely) missing from many of us ?abled? persons.

I am disturbed that anyone could forcibly submit a twelve year-old boy to a medical procedure so uncertain in its specific consequence yet so certain in its permanence. The sad thing is that it ended not because of its results or because of the moral implication of its application to vulnerable persons but because psychotic drugs obsoleted the procedure.

It should also be noted that the production quality is very good. The opening tapestry of voices is very well done and would pull listeners in.

Somehow it reminds me of Dicken?s ?Christmas Story? because it gave me the gift of reflection and gratitude of life?s blessings. Perhaps it will do the same for other listeners. I hope they get a chance to hear it.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of My Lobotomy

A chilling program. I like the use of a lobotomy patient to host the program. It probably opened doors to fellow lobotomy patients and their families. It certainly brought an intimacy to a story about a sterile medical procedure. Many of us know the term "lobotomy"; this makes it all so terribly real.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of My Lobotomy

This is a truly moving piece. Especially poignant. I like how it combines historical info with such a deeply personal narrative.

Production, use of music and various voices is top notch. Especially weaving different voices together in the intro.