Comments for Sweet Phil from Sugar Hill

Caption: the producer with her parents

Produced by Phyllis Fletcher

Other pieces by Phyllis Fletcher

Summary: A man has 14 children with 13 different women, dies young, and leaves them to learn about him through each other, and through the letters he wrote from prison.
 

User image

Review of Sweet Phil from Sugar Hill

In this first-person radio exploration, a young woman makes her way through a series of interviews with extended family members in an attempt to better understand her father, a man of mystery, much charisma, and a questionable moral compass. I'm hesitant to say too much about what producer Phyllis Fletcher learns along the way because one of the most captivating things about this story is the sequence of perfectly-paced revelations that get dropped on us as the narrative progresses.

Fletcher talks to almost 20 different relatives during her quest, and she boils it all down to a half-hour radio story (I can only imagine how much tape must have ended up on the cutting floor). The result is a tight, fast-moving tale with a lot of twists, turns, and emotional highs and lows, seasoned throughout with interludes of vintage soul, rock, and Latin jazz music? Can you believe this piece was a debut effort? Really nicely done.


Review of Sweet Phil from Sugar Hill

Beautiful piece! Ms. Fletcher combines the voices of her family, along with well-chosen musical interludes, to create a portrait of her deceased father. Anyone listening to the piece will fall a little in love with her dad, as well as the rest of her family.

User image

Review of Sweet Phil from Sugar Hill

Now here's a little gem of a personal piece. Producer Phyllis Fletcher has put together a charmer - poignant, hopeful and funny - about her father who had 14 children with 13 different mothers. Fletcher goes in search of and connects with many of her siblings while we hear letters from her father read by her eldest brother. This is one provocative piece that begs questions about family life, relationships and the different paths a person can take. Although I could have done without the constant music tracks and let the piece breathe more, I would recommend this half-hour piece as a special for Black History Month, Women's History Month and definitely Father's Day.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Sweet Phil from Sugar Hill

This was a very well-produced segment. The pacing and length was about right, and some of the interview segments were particularly charming.

User image

Review of Sweet Phil from Sugar Hill

The characters truly are wonderful in this piece. The production work is rich. There are many different voices, but each manages to stay distinct, and so the piece is very dynamic and achieves most of its power from these different voices. I was particularly surprised by how well the reading of Phil's letters worked - having a relative read them was really a much better idea than having an actor do it. It seems to add an amount of self-reflexivity to the production (by keeping it all "in the family") that so many of these kind of personal narratives seem to lack. Great work.

User image

Review of Sweet Phil from Sugar Hill

An engaging personal story with characters we really get to know and care about.

User image

Review of Sweet Phil from Sugar Hill

Take that old Temptations rock song "Papa was a rolling stone, Wherever he laid his hat was his home..." (was it the 70's?) and multiply it by 14, and you have an idea what this half hour is all about. Masterfully told, and at once disturbing, honest, and even inspiring, this is a powerful story. And an important one as well, giving real meaning to the words 'family' and 'grace'.