Comments by Kerry Seed

Comment for "In The Beginning - Reporting Iraq"

User image

Review of In The Beginning - Reporting Iraq

I'm a sucker for stories about news creation. Despite including the voices of high profile journalists, Dexter Filkins, Anne Garrels, and Richard Engel, this story doesn't provide much insight into the lives or methods of the reporters. Rather, producer Bruce Wallace focuses on the reporters' candid recollections of the early days of the Iraq War.

This piece could be used to illustrate the difference between these backstage asides and the reporters' glossier published/broadcast output.

On the downside, the audio quality of this story is extremely poor, the interviews would benefit from more internal edits, and the narrator could sound more engaged.

Comment for "'The Mad Russian': Reflections of a Cold War Wrestling Villain"

User image

Review of 'The Mad Russian': Reflections of a Cold War Wrestling Villain

In the tradition of NPR's Todd Holzman, Baltimore-based producer Aaron Henkin uses sport (never mind that this "sport" is professional wrestling) to look behind the music (USSR national anthem) at the fascinating and moving story of one of the WWF's greatest heels, Nicolai "The Mad Russian" Volkoff.

Listeners will hear archival tape of televised matches mixed with the reflections of the meditating, vegetarian Volkoff of today. Henkin contrasts the chutzpah of a young man that would ask arenas full of stark raving rasslin' fans in the 1980s to sing the USSR's national anthem with the Volkoff's true feelings: he hated communism and fled to this country to escape Stalinist persecution.

At 15:27, this piece feels about three minutes too long, but listeners will love Henkin's thoughtful blend of action and cold war history, through the eyes of a man who was arguably one of America's most visible cold warriors.

Comment for "'The Mad Russian': Reflections of a Cold War Wrestling Villain"

User image

Review of 'The Mad Russian': Reflections of a Cold War Wrestling Villain

In the tradition of NPR's Todd Holzman, Baltimore-based producer Aaron Henkin uses sport (never mind that this "sport" is professional wrestling) to look behind the music (USSR national anthem) at the fascinating and moving story of one of the WWF's greatest heels, Nicolai "The Mad Russian" Volkoff.

Listeners will hear archival tape of televised matches mixed with the reflections of the meditating, vegetarian Volkoff of today. Henkin contrasts the chutzpah of a young man that would ask arenas full of stark raving rasslin' fans in the 1980s to sing the USSR's national anthem with the Volkoff's true feelings: he hated communism and fled to this country to escape Stalinist persecution.

At 15:27, this piece feels about three minutes too long, but listeners will love Henkin's thoughtful blend of action and cold war history, through the eyes of a man who was arguably one of America's most visible cold warriors.

Comment for "The Gas Game: You Can Help Solve Our Energy Crisis!"

User image

Review of The Gas Game: You Can Help Solve Our Energy Crisis!

UC Irvine professor, Peter Navarro's image rich and lively take on our energy crisis is a refreshing departure from dry academic commentaries. Navarro puts listeners right into the action, vividly describing a car accident and his ensuing love affair with a rental Prius.

Comment for "Letters from Prison"

User image

Review of Letters from Prison

Gloria Diaz has produced a stirring and eloquent story that captures the range of emotions experienced by families tangled in the corrections system.

Diaz takes a lot of risks here by boldly sharing her emotions. Listeners benefit when they hear raw expressions of her grief and anger at losing her brother for the duration of his ten year sentence.

Comment for "Lessons Learned: Preventing School Violence" (deleted)

User image

Review of Lessons Learned: Preventing School Violence (deleted)

This conventional sounding program begins with the unaffected voice of Brian Walker, a survivor of a San Diego school shooting. Rebecca Cressman's narration contextualizes the stories of people who've had first hand experience with school violence, merging it with the informed analysis of academic, Richard Long.

I have heard several radio programs analyzing school shootings, but this one stands out due to Long's insight. He studied numerous incidents of school violence, and is able to bring a very concrete perspective to the issue while examining the causes of school violence side-by-side with plans to prevent such acts in the future. His findings will make this segement a valuable add for any PD wanting to address local school violence -- before or after it happens.

Comment for "Queer Youth Challenges" (deleted)

User image

Review of Queer Youth Challenges (deleted)

Due to the dearth of popular attention paid to the US foster care system, any time the media turns its attention to foster care, the audience wins. This episode of Making Contact looks at foster care issues through the eyes of some of the most underserved foster youth, the LGBTQ kids who pass through foster care, experiencing a unique set of issues from discrimination to abuse.

According to the program, "It's estimated that 25% of LGBTQ youth are forced to leave their family of origin as a result of conflicts around their sexuality."

This important show is compellingly produced, bringing together a wide range of experts and youth who have first hand experience with these issues. I would have liked to hear more youth voices, but this doesn't detract from an outstanding program that will be an asset to any broadcast day.

Comment for "Just the Facts Please, OKthx"

User image

Review of Just the Facts Please, OKthx

Chase Clyde is a bit of a speed reader, but his critique of media coverage of the war in Iraq is well-informed and pointed. Clyde presents a litany of facts about the justification for the war that are unfortunately still not discussed in mainstream news coverage of the war. The cheeky tone made me chuckle. If this was a little shorter, I'd rate it even higher.

Comment for "Why I Want to Vote"

User image

Review of Why I Want to Vote

This touching story of Luis Sierra's decision to apply for US citizenship brings an authentic voice to the air. Sierra illustrates his well-conceived commentary with his father's account of family history and with sound of himself applying for US citizenship. The 2004 election was a motivating factor for Sierra's changing his citizenship, and the sound here is that of a man coming of age, choosing his own path in life.

Comment for "Primary Sources - Kimberly's Friend" (deleted)

User image

Review of Primary Sources - Kimberly's Friend (deleted)

Many young people are now just as overscheduled as adults. As this feature illustrates, this can lead to a sense of isolation when doing homework late at night. One intriguing solution to this problem is proferred in Kimberly's Friend: Kimberly has created a friend-bot on her home computer. Listeners hear a touching profile of the artificial friend. I wanted to hear more about how she created the other Kimberly.

Comment for "Translating"

User image

Review of Translating

Carlos Guzman, a Latino living in the US, reflects on the experience of being the best English speaker in his home. Voices of other young people, the social worker at Guzman's school, and a UCLA professor provide a multifaceted look at the extra responsibilities of kids who are translators for their parents.

The story is clear and concise, but it lacks the tension that would be revealed if we heard first person accounts of what happened when young people were asked to translate in adult situations such as doctor's visits.

Comment for "Million Martyrs"

User image

Review of Million Martyrs

Rafael Casal's sense of rythym, rhyme, and verse are stunning. In Million Martyrs he turns his laser of lyrical lightning onto the mighty foes of commercialism, consumerism and capitalism. The result is a poem I cannot recommend highly enough for your special Poetry Month programming. This is a must add.

Comment for "Remote Control"

User image

Review of Remote Control

Poet Alicia Zakon's ode to self-determination is a perfect fit for Poetry Month or any program examinging power in relationships and/or domestic violence.

Describing power in a relationship as a metaphorical remote control passed between the two parties, Zakon says:

Why you let him play you like a video?
Turn you on and off like a radio?
Tell YOU when to go
fast and slow?
Change you channels 'cause he can't stand your show?

Comment for "In a Bubble"

User image

Review of In a Bubble

Those kids in the halls who don't talk, who are withdrawn into themselves - silently sitting through class, silently walking the halls, silently eating lunches - open up to producer Hillary Frank in this simple, thought provoking feature.

Program Directors will love this fresh way of looking at the daily challenges of high school. Frank steps outside of the news format ususally used to focus on the issues of young people, bringing a vulnerable, first person collage of rarely used voices to the air.

Comment for "Slip of the Tongue"

User image

Review of Slip of the Tongue

Program Directors looking to bring fresh voices to the air during Poetry Month or the upcoming Public Radio Collaboration on Globalization will delight in the rhymes flowing from Adriel Luis, a finalist at the Youth Speaks Grand Slam Poetry Finals in San Francisco.

Fine.
I'll tell you about my ethnic makeup
I wear the foundation
layed by my indigenous poeple...

Luis' lyrical talent is impressive, his delivery self-assured, his narrative something we all want and need to hear on the air.

Comment for "Last Goodbye"

User image

There Are No Hosts Here

A fresh episode of 'This One Time' from Bard College's WXBC, "Last Goodbye" is everything that is right about radio today.

No hosts interpret the experiences of the young voices here. Instead we hear unfiltered first person stories of painful goodbyes, last goodbyes.

Like an emo mixtape in which every song is all about you, these short stories of a young woman running away from a turbulent home, divorce, suicide, car accidents and broken hearts ring true with the vivid imagery of ordinary moments turned to touchstones in the lives of their narrators. What could have been saccharine in other hands, emerges here as a collection of authentic voices.

Music beds from Bjork, Yo La Tengo, and Will Oldham among others are used to expert effect.

**PD's note that this piece contains explicit language, and it begins and ends with a station ID for the station of origin, WXBC.

Comment for "Uniquely Human ? How We Nurture Skin and How It Nurtures Us" (deleted)

User image

Review of Uniquely Human — How We Nurture Skin and How It Nurtures Us (deleted)

This final episode in PRI's series, Skin Revealed, focuses on skin as palette, telling stories about skin modification and decoration from circumcision to tattooing.

This special has a conservative sound, similar to an NPR news magazine. The style is a tad dry, but it's informative and well suited for a general audience.

Comment for "Defunct-Second Opinion #1"

User image

Praise the Lord and Pass the Mic

Podcasting DJ Brad Morley has assembled a collection of punk tunes in the form of a nineteen minute set complete with DJ breaks announcing the tunes. I particularly enjoyed the opportunity to hear local punk acts from Morely's hometown of Flint, MI.

While this is professionally produced in a community radio sort of way, it really is not fit for terrestrial broadcast both because of the language and because of the program's odd length.

Comment for "Me and My Monkey"

User image

Review of Me and My Monkey

In this investigative essay, Stanford sophomores, Steven Tagle and James Madsen, enter the bowels of Stanford and encounter the a world in which the minute genetic difference between humans and primates is on display - an animal research laboratory.

Listeners will quickly note that there are some glaring levels issues here, that the piece is far too long, and that it is written in more of a print than a radio style, and that while Madsen is frequently mentioned, he is peculiarly absent from the piece. In short, this piece is not quite ready for prime time.

But, I think it is close. I suspect what is really missing here is a seasonded radio editor. All of its flaws aside, I truly enjoyed the access this piece provided into a hidden world where scientists develop such close relationships with the primates they are testing that they need counseling in order to deal with the harsher realities of their jobs. Tagle's voicing is fresh and energetic, and his storytelling style is engaging. I look forward to hearing more of Tagle's work in the future.

Comment for "BeautifulPeople.dk"

User image

Review of BeautifulPeople.dk

This profile of a Danish Hot-or-Not online dating community is on the money in terms of delivering a technically proficient, clean sounding, and informative piece on narrowcasting taken to new extremes.

Where the piece falters though is in its precise and calculated sound. This listener wanted the narrator to have more fun with the piece. A light feature such as this seems the perfect opportunity to experiment with your sound, to have fun with pacing, to bask in the opportunities of our radio universe.

Comment for "Queer Youth Valentine"

User image

Review of Queer Youth Valentine

Any Valentines related programming could benefit from these young GLBTQ voices. Instead, it's light and irreverent. It's a welcome youth produced antidote to a holiday that's generally played very straight in the media and in the popular conciousness.

Comment for "Who's Family?: Queerspawn Respond" (deleted)

User image

Review of Who's Family?: Queerspawn Respond (deleted)

The media's dialog surrounding lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer (LGBTQ) families rarely includes the voices you'll hear in this short vox-pop. This raw collage of voices ponders the question, "who's in your family?" In answering the question, these young adults reflect on the varied experiences they are living as the children of LGBTQ parents. The resulting piece will do much to inform any conversation about the expansive and selective nature of families. The production value is lean and mean, but the impact of these voices lasts far beyond the ninety seconds it will take you to air this important piece.

Comment for "Chuck Berry and Rock & Roll"

User image

Review of Chuck Berry: 50 Years of Rock & Roll

Producer Lester Graham brings enthusiasm and detailed research to this spirited biopic of the first person inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, The Living Legend, Chuck Berry. Interspersed with Graham's narration are cuts of Berry's hits and interviews with musicologists, Berry's bandmates, and the Man himself. Covering the highs and lows of Berry's career, this feature is a rockin' good listen.

Comment for "Martin Luther King Jr.: A Champion of Labor"

User image

Review of Martin Luther King Jr.: A Champion of Labor

Commentator Dick Meister writes a compelling commentary, covering Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s underdocumented relationship to the labor movement. The script is detailed and sourced. Unfortunately, Meister's reading style and production are not nearly so eloquent; the commentary is marred by several verbal stumbles and some mic noise that should be corrected before this goes on the air.

Comment for "Keeping Pace with Professional Dog Walker Matt Fisher"

User image

Review of Keeping Pace with Professional Dog Walker Matt Fisher

After a short introduction by Henkin, listeners hit the streets for a stroll with Matt Fisher and his charges. It's a light, breezy look into the life of a local gem, Professional Dog Walker Matt Fisher. Hear about the economics of dog walking, the challenges and the satisfaction it provides Fisher. This is a pretty long piece considering its high fluff content, but would be a good show closer.

Comment for "Interview with Juliana Hatfield"

User image

Review of Interview with Juliana Hatfield

In this interview, Juliana Hatfield joins WUSM Music Director Clinton Kirby by phone. Kirby mixes the converstation with select cuts from the latest Hatfield album, "In Exile Deo". Kirby's eager questions reflect his knowledge and appreciation of Hatfield's career. Hatfield's melancholic responses are often confrontational, bordering on the hostile. Kirby could have edited out the awkward interactions that ensue. Instead, he let's the tape roll, giving the audience a revealing look at this idol/idolator interaction. The finished product likely will appeal to die hard Hatfield fans who relate to her attitude.

Comment for "Meet Me at Unity Playlot"

User image

Review of Meet Me at Unity Playlot

Longhaul Productions has done a nice job of capturing this sound rich neighborhood struggle over the revitalization Chicago's Unity Playlot. The piece opens with a Joel Monarch song about the park, an innovative touch. While the piece is very Chicago-centric, little details (like the bit about Greek food) and well-realized characters make this a vivid tale, appropriate for listeners across the country. An uncommon story of citizens coming together in an insular age, this piece would complement any programming about democracy or community. Unfortunately missing from this piece are many voices of the young people who use the park.

Comment for "Metrology"

User image

Review of Metrology

Can you _imagine_ getting an assignment to cover a legal metrology conference? The thought causes a villainous bile to rise in my throat, slowly choking my will to live. A credit to reporters everywhere, producer Alan Coukell has fashioned an exciting, dynamic, and humorous piece about this very subject. All radio should be this lively. The narration is punchy, the interviews are varied and informative, and the mix is playful. My hat is off. Outstanding.

Comment for "Sisters"

User image

Review of Sisters

This collage of voices melds generations of sisters, talking about one another. You don't often voices of the very young mixed in the same piece with voices of the very old, but this piece knits them all together to talk about many facets of sisterhood. It's a simple feature about human relationships, and it's the kind of thing we don't hear enough of on the radio today.

Comment for "Stories1st: Elizabeth and Her Family"

User image

Review of Stories1st: Elizabeth and Her Family

Without mentioning the physical space inhabited by eleven-year-old Elizabeth Herrera, Elizabeth and producer Dmae Robert quickly transport listeners to a home bustling with youthful energy. Sometimes the piece just sounds like kids messing around with a microphone, but there is a lot beneath the surface in this short and sweet story. Wise beyond her years Elizabeth introduces listeners to her dancing siblings, and shares her pride in her mother's study habits. The most poignant moment comes when Elizabeth interviews her pregnant seventeen-year-old sister.