Comments by Charlotte Mcdonald

Comment for "Green Fashion Designers"

User image

Interesting, well-written feature

Aarti does a great job of using description to paint a picture of a completely visual medium: fashion. Her narration is fluid and never redundant; she manages to avoid the common trap of explaining what a piece of tape will say instead of letting it speak for itself. Aarti makes the feature personal at the end by discussing what she learned from her research on Seattle's sustainable fashion world. This is a well-written piece that doesn’t allow the listener’s attention to drop even for a moment.

Comment for "A Tax on plastic bags"

User image

Solid feature on plastic bag legislation

Aviva does a good job delving into her subject immediately by giving listeners a scary plastic bag statistic and explaining the proposed law. As this traditional newsy mixed feature unfolds, she continues to drive her points home with jarring images and hard facts about the realities of plastic bags. Some transitions between narration and tape could use work, but overall Aviva has done a good job. Her sources seem very credible and deliver a clear point of view on this environmental issue in Alaska.

Comment for "The Tragic End Of Summer Soundwave"

User image

Not too cohesive, but at least they're upfront about it

Summer Soundwave was a truly ambitious Weekday High summer program where kids produced features four days a week during August of 2010. The girls who produced this episode, the last one of the season, are very understandably bummed about the program's end and apologize for the lack of a theme that unifies this episode. They shouldn't--the two features are both very strong: interesting topics, solid editing, and professional-sounding narrator voices. It reminded me a little of This American Life (it covers the cool, small-town stories that get overlooked in hard news shows) but was clearly a youth show in its freshness and the banter between the hosts. Best line: "I'm concerned about the equipment over there getting wet...with your tears."

Comment for "Downtown Portland"

User image

Fresh tone, could go further

Ashley brings a fresh, relaxed, and unpretentious tone to this look at the city of Portland. She definitely succeeds in removing the stigma of danger from the city's downtown. I think that Ashley could have gone a little father with her feature, though. She could have talked with residents of downtown about cool stuff to do instead of listing activities herself. It also would have been helpful for listeners from outside Portland if Ashley had explained the danger stigma and its consequences on the city a little further. As it is, this piece is kind of hard to relate to for the majority of listeners.

Comment for "Civics and Conservation Summit"

User image

Interesting piece on state government

This feature showcases a cool program that gives Alaskan teenagers the opportunity to see how state government works. It could benefit from more student perspectives, and maybe an interview from a legislator about his or her opinion of the program. But this piece has a clear narrative flow and does a good job showing diverse aspects of the summit. It seems like a great way for students to really learn first-hand how state government works.

Comment for "On the trail with his dogs"

User image

A fascinating peek into the world of mushing

This is another strong feature from the Alaska Teen Media Institute. Ishmael uses an interview with musher Seiji Takagi to thoroughly explore this fascinating and little-known sport. Ishmael steps back and lets Seiji's story speak for itself, with background noise provided by the dogs from time to time. The anecdote about Seiji's brother's finish in the junior Iditarod really adds color to the piece. We also get to hear from Seiji's mom briefly, which is a nice touch.

Comment for "Beautiful Winter"

User image

Fun short piece

Kaila makes the most of the one-minute format to deliver a nice piece about what there is to appreciate about winter. What's Real is a really cool series put out by KBEM in Minnesota. Most of the features in this series deal with more serious topics, like succeeding in high school or dealing with racial prejudice. The light tone of Kaila's piece sets it apart, and the music she chose enhances it as well.

Comment for "In The Land Of The Summer"

User image

Surprising, mysterious

We usually think of youth-produced features as news, commentaries, vox pops, or public affairs pieces, so Marzia's story is a refreshing change. I loved the juxtaposition of her reading with the sound effects and background music. Marzia's vocal delivery lends a formal tone to a story that seems lighthearted at some moments, dystopian at others. music. Unexpected turns of phrase like, "What is the place you want so much?" surprised me and kept me listening through to the end. But I couldn't shake the feeling that the underlying message of the piece was something very, very dark.

Comment for "Dolna Smithback "Global Youth Leadership Institute""

User image

Engaging

Dolna could have edited the tape of the GYLI speaker a little more, as the strongest aspects of the feature are tape from other students and the segment about the Amistad schooner. In these sections of the piece, we really get a sense of what being at this conference felt like. This is where Dolna's voice comes through the clearest as well. By the end, we are invested in her as well as the GYLI conference. Dolna chose a good angle from which to approach the feature; the story about the storm provided direction to the piece. Overall, this is a great feature that sheds light on an interesting program.

Comment for "R U Green?"

User image

Funny, fast-paced

The sound effects and the fast pace of this feature immediately drew me in and kept me listening. Alexandros broaches some real questions that people who call themselves "green" should ask themselves, but does it in a funny and distinctly youth-radio way. More time spent on each question would have led to a more provocative and in-depth feature, but this approach is good because of the quick pace and the light tone. The piece me feel bad about everything I'm not doing to help the environment. It made me laugh as well. This must have required a lot of minute edits, and Alexandros does a good job there, too. It's professional-sounding and fun to listen to.

Comment for "HOWL!!"

User image

Authentic and smooth

This feature provides an interesting new take on the world of teenage wilderness programs. Not only does HOWL seem to take more risks than most adventure programs I’ve heard of (bear survival, anyone?), but it was also conceived by an 18-year-old girl who had just finished climbing Denali. The piece is very sound technically, although Aviva could tighten up the narration-to-music transition at the end of the piece. Interspersing HOWL program participants’ voices with narration and an interview of the founder creates a solid a youth-radio voice, but one of the best kind: authentic, easy to listen to, and smooth.

Comment for "Sew Spot Sew"

User image

Surprising and informative

The opening to this feature on the Do It Yourself movement certainly catches the listener off-guard--but it made me listen through to the end of the piece. And Sergio makes a convincing case for the value of being in touch with the stuff we use in our daily lives. The tone is lyrical at times, almost like a spoken word piece. Sergio hits a more traditional public radio stride after two minutes and really drives his points home. But he takes a risky and very effective to catch our attention--and it works. This piece would be a good addition to a show on conservation, globalization, or thriftiness in tough economic times.

Comment for "Water, A Universal Human Right"

User image

Youth review

Dolna Smithback’s feature reports on an event at the Parliament of the World’s Religions concerning clean water. The opening clip sets a great tone for Dolna’s piece by immediately establishing an international theme. Next she brings the topic home. Dolna pulls the listener in further by describing her experience growing up in New Mexico, where she had to be very aware of her personal water use. Next we move to the conference, where Dolna incorporates some great sourcing from attendees. I found hearing these diverse perspectives to be one of the most compelling aspects of the piece. The last speaker in particular really drives home all of Dolna’s points. The narrative transitions from one speaker to the next could use some revision; in most cases, Dolna has earned the right to make stronger statements than simply introducing the next speaker. This piece could be really inspiring to youth producers; it’s an example of how far you can take your work if you have the right resources. Dolna’s feature would work well on a show about the environment, international issues, or human rights.