Comments by Deborah Astley

Comment for "A MOMbo MOMent: Work/Home" (deleted)

User image

Review of A MOMbo MOMent: Work/Home (deleted)

What a great series. This particular piece, which I dub "To Work or Not to Work Outside the Home, That is the Question," is well produced, thoughtful, and balanced. The participants have the commonality of loving their children and wanting what is best for them. Many interesting scenarios and questions are presented. No answers or solutions are given because, while not blatantly stated in the piece, the listener will draw the conclusion that to work or not to work outside the home is a very personal decision for each family. This piece would work well around a segment about business or family.

Comment for "Kasper Hauser: Phone Call to the 14th Century"

User image

Review of Kasper Hauser: Phone Call to the 14th Century

This piece has everything a public radio listener requires: humor, information, and inventiveness in its presentation. Imagine you are stalled in traffic, stewing because your life is one long traffic jam. But you're tuned to your local public radio station so at least you are being informed and entertained. At five minutes before the top of the hour out of the radio comes lots of brass, applause, and the words, "Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to America's favorite game show. It's time to make your phone call to the 14th century." Three contestants have 30 seconds to impart important information to the inhabitants of the 14th century. A satirical spoof on game shows, this piece is funny and in its own quirky way, thoughtful. Now you can sit in traffic and think, "If I could make a 30 second phone call to the 14th century, what would I say them?" And that is what public radio does -- it makes you think.

Comment for "Before & After: The Second Spirit of a One-Eyed Photographer"

User image

Review of Before & After: The Second Spirit of a One-Eyed Photographer

This is a thoughtful, sensitive interview piece with a woman who fell, got up, fell again, and . . . got up again. For this reviewer, the most touching part about the piece was when Maureen said, "I want to cry because I was acknowledged. I was present." This piece would work well on a weekend show -- Saturday or Sunday "All Things Considered?" -- when things slow down a bit and listeners can take the time to listen and reflect on what a gem of a piece they just heard on public radio.

Comment for "Everything is Relative"

User image

Review of Everything is Relative

All baby boomers are clutching at the last vestiges of youth, and we are only kidding ourselves if we deny it. Judah has written a frank, concise yet layered piece about facing his own mortality and, yes, his vanity. He has superficial malignant melanoma. "Isn't that redundant? Isn't all melanoma malignant," he asks. Clever use of words contrast the feelings of the individual with the remoteness of the medical profession as he gets lost in its terminology. For those listeners who have ever faced the uncertainty of whether one does or does not have cancer, this piece will bring it all home to them again. For listeners who have never experienced this singular event, this piece will shed light on the uncertainity an individual feels when hearing that single word "malignant." This piece would work well around the health segments; it would also work well during May which is Skin Cancer Awareness month.

Comment for "Lost In The Stacks"

User image

Review of Lost In The Stacks

This is a smart sexy piece about one of the most stimulating places on earth: the library. Surrounded by all those brains on shelves, how could the place not be an aphrodiasiac? Apparently Andre Picher picked up on this fact at an early age. The intimacy of Picher's voice draws in the listener. Having worked in a library for several years, it was interesting to hear the thoughts of one student who had been sent there for punishment. It always bothered me that the library was used as a place for punishment in public schools. My only complaint about the piece -- and it's a tiny one -- is the background music. Too dreamy, almost wet. I imagined jellyfish floating around with that music. But, other than that, this is a great piece with appropriate library background sounds. As Picher points out, the library is a noble place.

Comment for "Naked People"

User image

Review of Naked People

Richard Paul's piece is amusing and thought-provoking. It would work well on an afternoon Weekend Edition news magazine. Morning might be a little too early - we're all still staring bleary eyed at ourselves in the bathroom mirror. Great bits of music add oomph to the piece. I might add that while listening to Naked People, I was reminded of former U.S. Attorney General John Ashcroft's clothing of Lady Justice's bare breast during his tenure in Washington, D.C. He didn't want her breast peeking over his shoulder while he was giving press conferences.

Comment for "Catfish Noodling in Oklahoma"

User image

Review of Catfish Noodling in Oklahoma

Location, location, location. In what part of the world are your listeners sitting when they hear a piece on public radio? I'm sitting in southwestern Oklahoma. While I've never personally met a catfish noodler, I'm familiar with the sport; and while it does take a daredevil spirit, (perhaps aided by some alcohol), to thrust one's hand into the mouth of a catfish, I have never viewed the people who participated in the sport as part of an "oddball subculture" as alluded to by another reviewer. Granted noodling is not golf or tennis, but it's certainly a colorful sport. Scott Gurion's report takes the brilliantly colored radio spectrum and blasts it all over the air waves like a many hued paint gun. Audio is very clear. I felt like I was there with Thomas and Scott, bending over into the reddish brown waters of the North Canadian River, grubbing my fingers down into the sides of the riverbank, holding my breath, waiting for that first brush of a catfish's whiskers. Great piece for the summertime. Well done.

Comment for "The Thrill of the Unmarked Car"

User image

Review of The Thrill of the Unmarked Car

Try as we might, usually we all end up being walking billboards for some company. It is such a huge part of our consumer society that we rarely give the phenomenon a second thought. Mr. Meister, though, has taken the courageous step of requesting that the name of his car be removed - not the car dealer's name, mind you -(although I'm confident that the dealer's name is long gone from his car)- but the brand name of the car! Very bold move. Short interesting piece. Catchy title.

Comment for "Eleanor Roosevelt"

User image

Review of Eleanor Roosevelt

This is a review of the series. Where we once were and where we are today - these moments are public radio at its best - sparkling gold dust in the form of snippets of voices from the past. Enough is said in each moment, though, to give listeners food for thought. These moments are why I love public radio.

Comment for "Where Is Sean Penn When We Need Him?" (deleted)

User image

Review of Where Is Sean Penn When We Need Him? (deleted)

Amen. Bravo. Amen. Timely commentary about all the focus on fluff. Cruise and Holmes - who cares? Piece is short and entertaining.

Comment for "Mingling Pen and Plow"

User image

Review of Mingling Pen and Plow

"The moment when Henry (Beston) died, all the lights in the house went out." Handel and Hayden Society Chorus's rendition of O Magnum Mysterium was playing in the background as I listened to this wonderful, well written piece about Chimney Farm and its owners, authors Henry Beston and Elizabeth Coatsworth, and their daughter, poet Kate Barnes; and booksellers and Chimney Farm's caretakers, Gary Lawless and Beth Leonard. The combination gave me chills. The house at Chimney Farm is full of books; when there was no more room in the house, the books spilled over into the barn. The sounds of the barn are particularly good. I love this barn: a great creaking door and the rustling of straw, plus oodles and oodles of books. Perhaps Elizabeth Coatsworth was referring to Chimney Farm when she wrote, "The sunset caught me, turned the brush to copper, set the clouds to one great roof of flame about the earth." Public radio is a favorite of book lovers and lovers of books will enjoy this piece. Give it a listen. This piece is poetry.

Comment for "Five Quick Ways to Save Money"

User image

Review of Five Quick Ways to Save Money

Great piece for high school age and college age people. Older people will benefit also because, while some might feel that the piece is stating the obvious, sometimes the obvious needs to be restated. The information is presented with such energy and great music that it will catch anyone's ear.

Comment for "I Wish"

User image

Review of I Wish

What a provocative word is wish. This collage of people's wishes, hopes and dreams is perfect for a starry summer's night when one is sitting outside watching the moon rise and waiting for that first falling star. Listeners will enjoy hearing what other people wish for. Put the piece in a quiet time.

Comment for "Happy Anniversary"

User image

Review of Happy Anniversary

Enjoyed this segment of the Sixty Second Radio Hour very much. The push and pull repartee between the man and the woman is clever. A long relationship has many phases and this short piece touched on all of them. It would be timely at any time of the year, not just on Valentine's Day. Anniversaries occur on every day of the year. It's good for some smiles and chuckles.

Comment for "Buckets of Gold"

User image

Review of Buckets of Gold

The human spirit is amazing. What one person finds irresistible, another will ignore. Lu Olkowski has created a piece that showcases Linda Stanley and her passion for sea glass. It is always wonderful to hear a person speak about something he or she loves to do - the voice rises, the intensity increases, details pour forth - the listener will hear all this in this quiet piece about searching for sea glass. Linda is so passionate about sea glass that she cautions that some sea glass is pulled from the ocean too soon. If it is too rough, it should be thrown back to be polished some more. This piece is polished and would fit in anywhere. I wish I lived by an ocean.

Comment for "Roadway Renaissance Man"

User image

Review of Roadway Renaissance Man

"You're as much coming into their world as they are coming into yours." When people drive through Tom Nunes's toll booth, they are in the presence of an empathetic, intelligent man who is a good example of the saying, "Bloom where you are planted." I have a feeling Tom Nunes would be happy anywhere, doing anything. Love this piece - the man, the music, the story. It would be perfect for drive-time news magazine shows. Excellent.

Comment for "Wintergreen Oil" (deleted)

User image

Review of Wintergreen Oil (deleted)

So wintergreen does more than freshen breath and make sparks in the dark? (Wintergreen Lifesavers) The casual tone of these conversational pieces about various areas of science are always enjoyable. However, the toxicity of wintergreen, while discussed, should have been emphasized a little bit more. Herbs are not regulated like pharmaceutical medication; as such, caveat emptor really does apply here. Having said that, this is a good drop in piece as are all of the pieces in the Natural Selection series.

Comment for "All in the Family"

User image

Review of All in the Family

To paraphrase Maya Angelou, "Families are more alike than unalike, and what is true anywhere is true everywhere." Scott Gurian's report on attending his family reunion bear out these words. Listeners will find commonality in Scott's piece as they hear him interact with his extended family. Enjoyable piece especially for this time of year which is popular for family reunions.

Comment for "Oxford, UK & Oxford, GA: Divided by a Common Tongue"

User image

Review of Oxford, UK & Oxford, GA: Divided by a Common Tongue

Clever drop-in piece that is perfect for the 4th of July weekend . . . or any time for that matter. I enjoyed hearing the differences in dialect and common expressions as people from Oxford UK and Oxford GA USA answered the same questions put to them by Mr. Barasoain.

Comment for "The Alternative Source, June 25, 2005" (deleted)

User image

Review of The Alternative Source, June 25, 2005 (deleted)

I've listened to other segments of this news roundup and I love it. It always has a different spin on the current news that listeners would have to dig to find anywhere else plus everytime I listen to it, there is always something that makes me chuckle or gasp. Informational and entertaining at the same time.

Comment for "How to Sing the Star-Spangled Banner"

User image

Review of How to Sing the Star-Spangled Banner

Listeners will learn how to hit the high notes while singing the Star Spangled Banner, perhaps the most mangled national anthem in the world. This piece is refreshing, light and entertaining. While certainly appropriate for the 4th of July weekend, this is a great drop in for any time of the year. The giggles are great. (The description of the piece is almost as good as the piece itself - very tongue in cheek.)

Comment for "The Lost Colonies :How Jamestown Beat the Odds"

User image

Review of The Lost Colonies?:How Jamestown Beat the Odds

Did you know tobacco saved Virginia and is probably the reason why we had a revolution with England rather than France or Spain? This is my favorite kind of piece: a drop in that is short and entertaining, yet full of information from authoritative sources. Good piece for the 4th of July weekend when the focus is on the USA's birthday.

Comment for "The Art of Fearbusting" (deleted)

User image

Review of The Art of Fearbusting (deleted)

Step into the unknown and give this piece a listen. Susan Jeffers possesses a calm maternal voice; her advice, while not groundbreaking or earthshaking, is helpful and well thought out.

Comment for "Evolve Fish Interview"

User image

Review of Evolve Fish Interview

Good piece for the summertime traveling season and a guaranteed conversation starter. Don't you always notice when you pull up behind a car at an intersection and on the bumper is an evolve fish? This couple is passionate about their website and it's interesting to hear the reasons why. It will fit in with religion, politics or business. Well done.

Comment for "Bobby's Birds"

User image

Review of Bobby's Birds

Bobby's Birds would work well as an intro to The First Pigeon Race, also by Megan Hall. It sets up Bobby's interest in pigeons and also how he got involved with them in the first place. I liked the listing of the pigeons' names at the first of the piece.

Comment for "The first Pigeon Race"

User image

Review of The first Pigeon Race

This is an interesting, detailed piece about a little known hobby - pigeon racing. It would fit in nicely on a weekend news magazine program. Great sounds - the cooing of the pigeons and the flapping and fluttering of the wings as they took off on their race. I did have a little trouble hearing Bobby at times -- the sound level seemed to be a little low. But, except for that, I would enjoy hearing the piece on the radio.

Comment for "Hometown with Tom Roznowski" (deleted)

User image

Review of Hometown with Tom Roznowski (deleted)

I listened to all six of these pieces and they are well done. The intro's low train whistle and the first few notes of Aaron Copeland's "Our Town," along with Roznowski's low key voice beckons the listener back in time. Programmers, if you have a small bit of time just before the 10 p.m. or 11 p.m. hour, try airing this. It is interesting to listen to, yet very relaxing. It would also fit just before Keillor's PHC or perhaps around a big band hour, but it can also stand alone. The world can be too much with us and these pieces illustrate just how remote we are from that world of 1926. Perfect for summertime.

Comment for "Is Capitalism Failing Middle America?"

User image

Review of Is Capitalism Failing Middle America?

So now non-reproducible seeds are being genetically engineered so that farmers have to buy new seed each year rather than harvest seed from existing plants? This is a scary piece that needs to be aired. Some things I knew, some things I didn't. Mr. Barnes lays out his case with great authority and leaves listeners with questions for which only time can give the answers. Very thought provoking. This would certainly be a "wake me up, get the adrenaline going" piece.

Comment for "Metrology"

User image

Review of Metrology

I always wondered what life was like in the time of the sundial - was it more vague, less precise perhaps? It must have been a convention of metrologists that brought that vague time to an end. This is a very interesting piece on the science of measuring and measurements; while it sounds like an incredibly dry topic, it isn't. The piece is full of anecdotes well suited for the layperson. Find out what daphnias are and why they are important to measurements. How many daphnias can one fit on the head of a pin? Well done.

Comment for "Million Martyrs"

User image

Review of Million Martyrs

Rafael Casal wraps and twists his tongue around the English alphabet, lashing out at all the ills of our society. Hard-hitting and inciteful, I was exhausted after listening to this piece. Weekends would be a good time to hear this piece because it deserves our full attention. (For some odd reason Emily Dickinson's "The Soul Selects Her Own Society" popped into my mind while listening to this piece.)