Comments for Worlds of Difference: Finding a Niche

Piece image

This piece belongs to the series "Worlds of Difference"

Produced by Homelands Productions for NPR

Other pieces by Homelands Productions

Summary: A sound-rich documentary about the efforts of traditional societies to find a niche in the global marketplace, with stories from Peru, Canada, Scotland and Mexico.
 

User image

Review of Worlds of Difference: Finding a Niche

Homelands Productions' Worlds of Difference series has been delivering some of the very finest material to air on public radio over the past two years. WOD has subtly infiltrated the magazines and other high-profile shows with full-segment and segment-breaking pieces that, subversively, achieve a real connection with listeners.

Here, for example, Chris Brookes's segment on Newfoundland sings, literally. "For five centuries, we sang, we danced, we spoke the language of fish. Our culture was their voice." It's not just the English language and absence of voiceover – the fishermen here deliver a nuanced and compelling story – becoming fishers of people instead of fishers of cod -- and Brooks' participatory narrator is perfect pitch.

But as an hour-long package, "Finding a Niche" seems like more is less. The overall presentation feels padded and plastic. Maria Hinojosa's narration and the snippets of gratuitous listen-to-my-title-and-accent commentary feel like shrinkwrap over handwoven material, a slick, shiny covering that renders some of the contents airless.

The challenge of compelling coverage of globalism is to get past earnest eat-your-peas journalism. The pieces from Peru and Mexico are stuck firmly in the vegetable niche, though. We don't use chemicals in our potatoes. We don't use chemicals in our mescal. It's still pretty much the didactic stick without too many sweet carrots.

Vera Frankl's examination of the Outer Hebrides, though, is a deeper story of physical detachment and digital connectedness – and that's the larger motif any reporting on globalization must reach for -- connecting with listeners who are detached from the wider world.

"Niche" finds virtuoso voice twice in four swings (and they're homers) – a pretty good batting average for delivering a series on the world, differently.

["Tones" refer to Segment II by Chris Brookes.]

User image

Review of Worlds of Difference: Finding a Niche

This collection of sound-rich documentaries on global marketing engage the listener with lively writing and interesting topics. The elements are woven together well, taking us on a journey through several communities struggling to find a place in the global marketplace. Well done!

User image

Review of Worlds of Difference: Finding a Niche

Hosted by Maria Hinojosa, this special tackles a broad and difficult topic skillfully. Hinojosa is a terrific host and just right as presenter of four stories exploring how traditional cultures are grappling with the rapid change of global economics. One of the things I like about this program is its willingness to examine the dark side of globalism. We do hear so much jingoistic coverage of this topic.

Included is a haunting and poetic piece about the demise of the cod-fishing industry in Newfoundland, one of those radio stories that gently yet firmly grabs your lapels and won’t let you go. The first and last stories are from Peru and Mexico and are very well-researched and put together, though not as intriguing, perhaps because, as an earlier review noted, they are more narrator-driven. I did find the Mexican town’s efforts to market its local liquor interesting, though. A piece about the Outer Hebrides of Scotland is also well-produced (and, of course, has those yummy accents!)

This is a serious piece of journalism that provides nice international coverage of a timely and important topic. I think many public radio listeners will find it significant, akin to reading international coverage in the New York Times.

User image

Review of Worlds of Difference: Finding a Niche

This polished production should fit any station's Think Global remit. Four sound rich stories from four countries where traditional societies cope with the changing global economy. But the first and last items from Peru and Mexico are very narrator driven, probably due to language differences. So much information is related, it begins to overwhelm the sound and feeling of the places and people who live there. The item from Scotland's Outer Hebrides was able to focus on the people - but why is the piece split in half with a station ID break? This interruption hurt the pace of the story and seemed unnecessary when it could'v been slotted in between two complete stories. But without a doubt, the jewel in this hour is Chris Brookes' poetic piece about the collapse of the Newfoundland cod industry where a whole town has vanished leaving only a dance to remember it by. A fascinating story, beautifully paced and produced, it's worth playing the whole hour just to let your listeners hear this bit of audio wizardry.