Comments for Barry, Bob & Me

Caption: PRX default Piece image

Produced by Brian Beatty

Other pieces by Brian Beatty

Summary: An aspiring writer discovers that inspiration and imitation aren't the same thing.
 

User image

Review of Barry, Bob & Me

Not knowing what you're talking about, I have a hard time knowing what to say about this piece. I hear this piece and I say "Uh-huh" and then I go on to the next thing I'm doing. I'm guessing it's because I haven't a clue who Barry Hannah is or what his writing sounds like.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of Barry, Bob & Me

This is a very honest and interesting piece about Beatty’s seven year attempt to emulate the prose of his favorite writer, Barry Hannah. It captures the reverence we can feel for someone whose art we admire. It also reveals how this admiration can lead us into an obsessive and detrimental one-way relationship. Beatty.admits that he gave up trying to write in his own style and out of his own experience in order to simply recreate the work of Barry Hanna, as he considered him to be both a superior writer and person. The piece is never sad though and remains funny throughout. Beatty’s honesty and candor about his own misguided path gives this piece its lightness of touch. Indeed the very act of holding up a mirror to himself and his past has allowed him to become a talented essayist in his own right. As with most good stories, this piece transcends the author’s own experience and reflects universally on the relationship that people have with art and artists that they admire. Virtually all of our lives have been influenced in some capacity by the artists that we admire. In many instances, this influence has yielded positive results. Other times, as followers of Sid Vicious and Kurt Cobain can attest, the results can be destructive. In this case the results are bitter sweet.

User image

Review of Barry, Bob & Me

This piece is so revealing that I found myself being embarrassed for Mr. Beatty. It's well done, with wonderful background music that picks up on the wistfulness of the words being spoken. Writers and those who love to read - which makes up a large part of the public radio audience -will enjoy this short piece about a person coming to terms with reality. Great job.

User image

Review of Barry, Bob & Me

Unlike other pieces by this author, this one is just entrancing. The pace is slower but perfect for getting the listener to focus on the story. There seems to be a real jelling of story and pace that makes you wonder what will happen next. It's very personal and close to a discovery of self that would work well on This American Life.

User image

Review of Barry, Bob & Me

This is a great piece! I love the voice, the premise, and the pacing. The commentary moves from broader, philosophical scale to a focused scene and back to philosophizing, and remains clear and easy to follow the entire time. It's personal but has plenty of elements for a wide variety of listeners to connect with: While it's primarily about writing and the creative process, it's also about role models and finding our own personal style in whatever we do. The music matches the voice well. I might have chosen something less obviously "writerly" sounding, and at some point the music's constant presence became slightly distracting. But these are small, highly subjective comments in an overall excellent production.