Piece Comment

Review of RN Documentary: Song of a Troubled Heart


The pairing of Mahler and Freud is a happy choice. Both shared the same intellectual climate of Mitteleuropa at the end of the 19th. century: progressive dissolution of ancient structures - political, social, personal and artistical – accompanied by a groping for the new, not yet fully perceived in its contours. As Gramsci said, “The old is dying and the new cannot be born. In this interregnum, there arises a great diversity of morbid symptoms." It would take a few decades and a world war for the new century to start gaining its shape but both Freud and Mahler were important pathfinders in their respective fields.

At the same time, both looked back at a rich tradition and felt an immense longing for the certainties of older times, made more acute by the knowledge that it belonged to the past. This longing perpasses Mahler's whole oeuvre and culminates in Das Lied von der Erde. And in the unfinished 10th. Symphony, written soon after Das Lied, Mahler anticipates many of the features of the second Viennese school. A similar parallel can be found in Freud studies of childhood and the necessity of living and transcending it to fully achieve adulthood.

An excellent piece, intelligent, well researched and especially clarifying without the use of condescending clichés.