I'm not sure what to make of this piece by producer Amanda Wells and that's a good thing. It's eerie. It's educational. It's an inside look at how cutting, or self-mutilation, caught on at one American school. A girl named Christie described her initiation to cutting this way: "I had an eating disorder going on at the time ... I didn't know what else to do. I would binge and purge each night and that didn't help anymore. I needed something more. Why not cut?" The reporter says 1 out of 10 teens cuts. Other reviewers have indicated that this piece appears to be pro-cutting and suggest offering it to listeners as part of a wider discussion on the subject of self-mutilation. That?s a valid point. But it?s seemingly unbalanced ending also serves another purpose: It puts the listener inside a world most of us never would venture. And that opens the door to understanding.
This piece is somewhat Dark to me not only because of the music and the mood but just by the words and the fact that it's real. This piece is pretty sad to me because it's such a common problem that many teens have. The music behind this piece really adds to the mood. The problems that these teens mention in this piece are some that I can relate to, but I could never bring myself to ever cut myself. That's why this is so scary to me...I must say I didnt really enjoy listening to this piece because it's so scary, but it's real and needs to be heard.
I think the issue of self-mutilation is an important and dangerous
one, however I feel that this piece could have covered it better. Some
of the descriptions, "games", and the music, were downright
disturbing. The feel the piece gave me was that the speaker was
pro-cutting. Also therer were some parts about teen sex which could
have been cut out, because they were irrelevant. The flow of the piece
was choppy, and while the topic is important, I think this piece needs
a lot of work, especially an overall change in tone.
Comments for This New Game
Produced by KRCB's Voice of Youth
Other pieces by KRCB Voice of Youth
Rating Summary
3 comments
Todd Melby
Posted on December 08, 2006 at 04:28 AM | Permalink
Review of Cutting
I'm not sure what to make of this piece by producer Amanda Wells and that's a good thing. It's eerie. It's educational. It's an inside look at how cutting, or self-mutilation, caught on at one American school. A girl named Christie described her initiation to cutting this way: "I had an eating disorder going on at the time ... I didn't know what else to do. I would binge and purge each night and that didn't help anymore. I needed something more. Why not cut?" The reporter says 1 out of 10 teens cuts. Other reviewers have indicated that this piece appears to be pro-cutting and suggest offering it to listeners as part of a wider discussion on the subject of self-mutilation. That?s a valid point. But it?s seemingly unbalanced ending also serves another purpose: It puts the listener inside a world most of us never would venture. And that opens the door to understanding.
sasha smith
Posted on August 29, 2005 at 12:10 PM | Permalink
Review of Cutting
This piece is somewhat Dark to me not only because of the music and the mood but just by the words and the fact that it's real. This piece is pretty sad to me because it's such a common problem that many teens have. The music behind this piece really adds to the mood. The problems that these teens mention in this piece are some that I can relate to, but I could never bring myself to ever cut myself. That's why this is so scary to me...I must say I didnt really enjoy listening to this piece because it's so scary, but it's real and needs to be heard.
Selomé Samuel
Posted on June 28, 2005 at 01:43 AM | Permalink
Review of Cutting
I think the issue of self-mutilation is an important and dangerous
one, however I feel that this piece could have covered it better. Some
of the descriptions, "games", and the music, were downright
disturbing. The feel the piece gave me was that the speaker was
pro-cutting. Also therer were some parts about teen sex which could
have been cut out, because they were irrelevant. The flow of the piece
was choppy, and while the topic is important, I think this piece needs
a lot of work, especially an overall change in tone.