Comments for First Trumpet Memories

Piece image

Produced by Adam Allington

Other pieces by Adam Allington

Summary: Trumpet player Irving Sarin recalls the strict disicpline of legenardy conductor Fritz Reiner
 

User image

Review of First Trumpet Memories

Irving Sarin's voice is cobblestone over which his trumpet solos pour smooth as water in Adam Allington's mix of "First Trumpet Memories", an interview detailing conductor Fritz Reiner and the Pittsburg Symphony Orchestra in the mid- 20th Century.

MDs with a classical music format will find plenty of opportunities for this erudite insider's look at the personalities of the symphony, but the specificity removes it from general-interest programming.

There's some hollow mic-ing at the intro, and when Sarin complains that under Reiner, "Life became torturous," Allington follows, cartoonishly, with the opening of Beethoven's Fifth – not exactly a showcase for trumpet – but, overall, the piece is produced and edited smoothly. A classic classical interview.

Caption: PRX default User image

Mr. Sarin retired to Bay City Michigan for a while

He came into and out of my life in the middle 60s and I took some lessons from him. I still have several etude books he gave me no nearly 50 years later.. he was gruff and no nonsense. I told him I got my audition letter back from Julliard as a conducting student and trumpet student and he just laughed. He said go find Mel at the Met and find a good theory teach who can teach you solfeggio and don't waste your money.

My parents were overjoyed.

Caption: PRX default User image

My time with Irving Sarin

Irving Sarin brought much of the Reiner discipline to the Wichita state University Brass Choir ensemble. Several members left after they we asked to play their parts in front of the entire choir. THose of us that stayed become very good indeed.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of First Trumpet Memories

Bravissimo! Irving Sarin's astute recollections and precise
memories of legendary conductor Reiner are refreshing,
and give insights into conductor / musician relationships.
As a former student of Sarin's ( late '60s ), it was quite refreshing
to hear my former teacher and mentor reminisce about
Fritz Reiner. I can attest that as a teacher and mentor, Sarin may have been just as demanding with his pupils, as Reiner was with his musicians.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of First Trumpet Memories

It would have been nice to hear in the backround a recording of Mr. Sarin playing with Reiner. There must be more interview than just 5 minutes. Irv can talk for ages. I know this as a former student of his. Let's hear it!


Review of First Trumpet Memories

Recalling his early work with Reiner, Sarin is able to convey to the audience a change in the way conductors are looked at over the decades. Although Reiner was strict with his musicians, perhaps too strict for today's sensibilities, Sarin's respect for him is coated with thankful reminiscence.

Caption: PRX default User image

Review of First Trumpet Memories

This interview with legendary Trumpeter Irving Sarin brings a great deal of insight to an earlier age of the life of an orchestral musician. Mr. Sarin's anecdotes of Fritz Reiner concisely show how the era of the dictatorial orchestral conductor evinced itself in an entertaining, yet informative manner.

Delightful trumpet features and other orchestral works punctuate the stories of one of the most powerful and talented conductors of the last century. Maestro Reiner, one of the last of the breed of the 'ultimate' orchestral conductors is shown to be both a wit and a tyrant, and the stories demonstrate the tenuousness of the professional life of the frontline classical musician in a highly entertaining manner.

Mr. Sarin, a highly esteemed veteran of the orchestral world, known for his ascerbic, 'take no prisoners' attitude, constructs a vivid portrait of the famous conductor as only someone could who is respectful of the art, sincerely devoted to his craft, and forced to live with the daily bombasts of a demanding, yet talented overlord.

This interview is an interesting look at the little known world (outside the arena of the classical musician) of both the instrumentalist and the conductor from an age when the conductor's word was law.

User image

Review of First Trumpet Memories

A finely made, colorful portrait with humor, warmth and honesty. I'm unfamiliar with the conductor, or rather I used to be - testimony to this good work. Somehow I think I could even guess what Reiner likes for breakfast. I wish there were some kind of series of this kind of portrait : accomplished artists talking about their mentors - it'd make a great drop-in.